AgTalk Home
AgTalk Home
Search Forums | Classifieds (117) | Skins | Language
You are logged in as a guest. ( logon | register )

Farmworks & GS2
View previous thread :: View next thread
   Forums List -> Precision TalkMessage format
 
Jacob Bolson
Posted 3/25/2008 23:06 (#341889 - in reply to #341694)
Subject: Re: Farmworks & GS2


Iowa
Muddy - 3/25/2008 19:47

You can't blame those for wanting to work with Deere. Deere doesn't make it very easy for others to work with their data.

Deere has got the iron business figured out but they have some work to do in the electronics business. I have some co-workers that process a substantial amount of data. From what I've learned, it sounds like each time there is a new GS2 firmware release the third party software companies (Farmworks, Ag Leader SMS, Mapshots, SST, etc.) have to reinvent the wheel to work with the changes.

Macy - 3/25/2008 21:40

For my two cents... the problem with trying to integrate with Deere is that we never see what all they can do until our customers have been out in the field and have done it. There are about 1300 ways (ok... a little exaggeration) that they log data. Most of those ways, like Trimble, were devised because they think they are doing us a favor. But... if they would just pick the most complex way of doing it, and make simple stuff look complex, life would get much simpler for all concerned.

Case in point. You are planting one variety in a field. So, they define a single "seeding" operation in the monitor, covering the full width of the machine. But, as soon as you say you want to record two varieties, they completely change the logging file format. There is no similarity between the two. The second format is much more complex. But guess what... we have to handle the second format anyway, so why try to "help us" by "dumbing down" single variety entry. Why not just give us a two-part planter with the same variety in both sides in the single-variety scenario?

The industry, at large, is crying for each vendor to generate a set of "golden data" and a narrative and spatial summary of what we should all be able to see from that data. What we get is a vendor's bench simulations during early design processes, and then we wait for our customers to give us the real stuff.


Is the JD RX converter something that you developed?
http://stellarsupport.deere.com/en_US/support/jdrx_converter/
Top of the page Bottom of the page


Jump to forum :
Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread

(Delete cookies)