Viewing a thread - Calling All Soil Experts/Economists....Fertility Questions

Forums | Classifieds (144) | Skins | Language

You are logged in as a guest. ( logon | register )

Calling All Soil Experts/Economists....Fertility Questions	View previous thread :: View next thread
Forums List -> Crop Talk	Message format

martin

Posted 12/30/2006 11:59 (#80453 - in reply to #80424)
Subject: RE: Short explanation on rock phsophate

Are you suggesting that rock phosphate just might work on his pH=5.1 soils.... that there is enough acid in the soil to break that rock phophate down?
but if he applies lime to get that pH up to 6.5-7, then the odds of rock phosphate breaking down in a timely fashion go right out the window?

Just asking for clarification here....

sounds like a quandary to be in .......

Edited by martin 12/30/2006 12:01

Calling All Soil Experts/Economists....Fertility Questions - NEMOScott : 12/29/2006 20:44
- Re: Calling All Soil Experts/Economists....Fertility Questions - Ed Winkle : 12/29/2006 20:57
  - Thanks for the thoughts Ed - NEMOScott : 12/29/2006 21:14
    - I'll leave the lime to those who understand it. - Hay Wilson in TX : 12/29/2006 21:46
      - Hay Wilson - NEMOScott : 12/29/2006 22:30
  - Re: Calling All Soil Experts/Economists....Fertility Questions - Ed Winkle : 12/29/2006 21:31
    - Ed Rock Phosphate??? - Phil A. : 12/30/2006 08:43
      - Short explanation on rock phsophate - Hay Wilson in TX : 12/30/2006 10:44
        
        RE: Short explanation on rock phsophate - martin : 12/30/2006 11:59
        
        Re: Calling All Soil Experts/Economists....Fertility Questions - Hay Wilson in TX : 12/30/2006 14:20
    - Re: Calling All Soil Experts/Economists....Fertility Questions - Silver Shoes : 12/30/2006 09:34
  - Re: Calling All Soil Experts/Economists....Fertility Questions - Joe Anchor : 12/30/2006 09:06
- Re: Calling All Soil Experts/Economists....Fertility Questions - plowboy : 12/29/2006 21:38
  - Re: Calling All Soil Experts/Economists....Fertility Questions - Hay Wilson in TX : 12/29/2006 21:57
  - Re: Ever do yield grids vs lime? - notillr : 12/30/2006 09:16
- Re: Calling All Soil Experts/Economists....Fertility Questions - mike in sw mn : 12/29/2006 21:49
- RE: Calling All Soil Experts/Economists....Fertility Questions - Robert in CenMo : 12/29/2006 21:51
- Thanks everyone - NEMOScott : 12/29/2006 22:17
  - RE: Thanks everyone - martin : 12/29/2006 23:04
- RE: Calling All Soil Experts/Economists....Fertility Questions - davpal : 12/30/2006 02:17
- throw us a bone... - robaer1 : 12/30/2006 02:35
  - Here is a representative soil test - NEMOScott : 12/30/2006 10:39
    - working beyond my level of ignorance - Hay Wilson in TX : 12/30/2006 11:25
      - RE: Maine - martin : 12/30/2006 17:56
        
        Re: Calling All Soil Experts/Economists....Fertility Questions - Hay Wilson in TX : 12/30/2006 20:36
    - RE: Here is a representative soil test - martin : 12/30/2006 12:04
      - Missouri does a different dance - NEMOScott : 12/30/2006 14:20
        
        RE: Missouri does a different dance - martin : 12/30/2006 17:44
    - Re: Calling All Soil Experts/Economists....Fertility Questions - Ed Winkle : 12/30/2006 15:15
- Re: Calling All Soil Experts/Economists....Fertility Questions - sri : 12/30/2006 23:54
  - Re: Calling All Soil Experts/Economists....Fertility Questions - JDPlowboy : 12/31/2006 00:54
  - SRI.... - martin : 12/31/2006 12:57
    - Details, Details - NEMOScott : 1/1/2007 16:11

Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread

(Delete cookies)