Viewing a thread - This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till

Forums | Classifieds (245) | Skins | Language

You are logged in as a guest. ( logon | register )

This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till	View previous thread :: View next thread
Forums List -> Crop Talk	Message format

NEILFarmer

Posted 6/28/2012 08:51 (#2454264 - in reply to #2454064)
Subject: Re: greener where ripped

Morris, IL

mhagny - 6/28/2012 05:49

NEILFarmer - 6/27/2012 21:27 About the sidewall compaction above. I found the strip till to have no sidewall compaction or very little. Basically when i was digging i couldn't find where disc went. Conventional broke apart in halves easily. Any idea? This was all normal deere rubber wheels.

Same soil texture and field history? Same down-pressure? Planted under identical moisture conditions, or was the strip-till slightly drier? (perhaps imperceptibly to us, but the roots know)

The strip-till was wetter. The conventional tillage was dry this year everywhere, the tillage equipment just dried out the soil. Both had enough moisture to plant 2" but strip till i could have planted 1.5".

Same soil texture besides one being worked and one not, same field history, same down pressure setting although conventional drew more pressure. If i had enough setting i could have taken off 50-75lb. the strip till.

Will say this, the strip till was dryer for top 1" then the conventional.

Edited by NEILFarmer 6/28/2012 08:53

This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - JK SCLA : 6/27/2012 17:45
- Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - northmofarm : 6/27/2012 17:50
  - Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - onslowfarm : 6/27/2012 17:57
  - Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - CaseFarmer : 6/27/2012 20:32
  - Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - tj_farmer : 6/27/2012 21:06
    - Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - NEILFarmer : 6/27/2012 21:17
      - Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - tj_farmer : 6/27/2012 21:25
- Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - cornstalk : 6/27/2012 17:53
  - Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - cainfarmer : 6/27/2012 18:02
  - Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - flatlick farmer : 6/27/2012 18:32
- Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - D6Joe : 6/27/2012 18:09
- Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - JohnDeereGreenWKY : 6/27/2012 19:12
  - Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - Shawn michigan : 6/27/2012 21:14
- Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - DRester : 6/27/2012 19:15
- RE: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - bleedred : 6/27/2012 19:16
- RE: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - mhagny : 6/27/2012 19:32
- Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - jd 9760 : 6/27/2012 19:41
  - Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - necaseih : 6/27/2012 19:56
    - Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - 4560fanz : 6/27/2012 20:28
      - Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - NEILFarmer : 6/27/2012 21:23
        
        Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - Midsize farmer : 6/27/2012 21:36
        
        Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - NoTill1825 : 6/28/2012 08:17
        Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - pbutler : 6/28/2012 16:09
  - Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - Duane NC OH : 6/27/2012 21:16
  - Re: don't forget about nutrient availability - mhagny : 6/27/2012 22:22
- Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - Manteno Mark : 6/27/2012 20:39
- No Till vs Conventional tillage discussions - Jim : 6/27/2012 21:13
  - RE: No Till vs Conventional tillage discussions - jalopy : 6/27/2012 23:35
  - RE: No Till vs Conventional tillage discussions - pbutler : 6/28/2012 16:10
- Something I've noticed - Mark (EC,IN) : 6/27/2012 21:15
  - Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - nviney : 6/27/2012 21:33
    - Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - tj_farmer : 6/27/2012 21:36
      - Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - nviney : 6/27/2012 21:51
        
        Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - tj_farmer : 6/28/2012 19:16
- Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - NEILFarmer : 6/27/2012 21:39
  - Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - steiger19 : 6/27/2012 22:02
    - Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - NEILFarmer : 6/27/2012 22:10
    - Re: greener where ripped - mhagny : 6/27/2012 22:13
      - Re: greener where ripped - NEILFarmer : 6/27/2012 22:27
        
        Re: greener where ripped - mhagny : 6/28/2012 06:47
        Re: greener where ripped - mhagny : 6/28/2012 06:49
        
        Re: greener where ripped - mhagny : 6/28/2012 06:52
        Re: greener where ripped - NEILFarmer : 6/28/2012 08:51
        
        Re: greener where ripped - mhagny : 6/28/2012 11:56
        
        Re: greener where ripped - NEILFarmer : 6/28/2012 14:39
        
        Re: greener where ripped - mhagny : 6/29/2012 06:42
  - Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - steiger19 : 6/27/2012 22:04
  - Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - mikeinok : 6/27/2012 22:48
    - Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - NEILFarmer : 6/27/2012 22:54
      - Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - mikeinok : 6/27/2012 23:02
        
        Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - NEILFarmer : 6/27/2012 23:07
- Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - Lookingglass : 6/27/2012 22:23
- Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - JK SCLA : 6/27/2012 22:39
  - Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - Jim : 6/28/2012 01:31
- Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - bigdirt : 6/27/2012 22:51
- RE: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - oilmaster : 6/27/2012 23:00
  - Subsoiling in dry fall only, no till spring seeding - Dutchdeutz : 6/27/2012 23:38
- RE: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - 7110mag : 6/27/2012 23:01
  - Re: This talk about the drought: Tilled vs. No-till - rab1964 : 6/28/2012 08:27

Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread

(Delete cookies)