Don't know which is best. We've got 3 ShurCos & we're happy. Ours are a couple of yrs old, so we don't have the new ShurCo motor, however we have the new style remote controls (fob & rcvr). We replaced one motor a few yrs ago. Not sure why. The motors on the older ShurCos are from Roll-Rite. But, other than that, they've been good for us. No problems. If we buy another trailer, it'll have a ShurCo also....that's "here".