AgTalk Home
AgTalk Home
Search Forums | Classifieds (41) | Skins | Language
You are logged in as a guest. ( logon | register )

Help me with the economics of a bin.
View previous thread :: View next thread
   Forums List -> Market TalkMessage format
 
dpilot83
Posted 11/17/2026 10:35 (#11804869 - in reply to #11800615)
Subject: RE: Help me with the economics of a bin.



“Bags are a fad”

Maybe. I got serious about bags in probably 2016.

Bought a Loftness unloader in early 2017 I believe. Already had a Loftness bagger before that.

Bought an Akron bagger in probably late 2017.

I think between the Loftness bagger and the Akron bagger I’m probably over 4M bushels through them at this point. Some years were poor years and at least one year it seemed like basis was great during harvest so almost everything went to town.

I would imagine at least 3.5M through the Loftness unloader.

This year I bought 720K bushels worth of bags. Cost me $35K or very close to it.

In the early days (pre-2016) before I took it more seriously I used a 4010 a fair amount for bagging and then some neighbors and my Dad and I shared a bag unloader.

Then from 2016 on for maybe 6 or 7 years I used a single 4430 JD tractor with around 14,000 hours on it as the bagger and bag unloader tractor. Over time I put a quick attach on the 158 loader and added a joystick with a 3rd function. Also added an Espar coolant fired diesel heater so it would start easy out in the field when it was cold.

About 3 years ago I finally added a 2nd 4430 and loader.

Then 2 years ago I really splurged and added a really low hour JD 6430 Premium MFWD with IVT and loader.

Over the years I probably spent $505K on the following things:

1st 4430 with loader set up right and Espar heater set up, 2nd 4430 with 265 loader set up right and Espar heater, first bagger, second bagger, unloader, 6430, major repaors, minor repairs and bags

If I sold all of the equipment today I think conservatively I would get $214K out of it.

So depreciation and repairs and the bags themselves over 4M bushels has cost me $291k. I think that works out to be $0.072 per bushel.

Of course on top of that you have labor and fuel. You also have opportunity cost. I guess I have always billed myself $0.12/bushel for the entire operation and I still feel like that’s pretty close.

In my area if I haul to the elevator during harvest I lose $0.28 of basis vs buyers coming to my field and hauling out of the bags with their trucks (freight on buyer).

I also spend $0.35 getting it to the elevator. Once you factor in the $0.12 bagging operation cost that works out to bagging being $0.51/bushel better than going to the elevator during harvest.

I would also need 3 or 4 trucks and drivers during poor years and probably 8 trucks and drivers during good years to get it all hauled out during harvest.

If I built myself an adequate bin site to handle my current production even if I used augers and didn’t have a dryer I would need to invest enough dollars that my opportunity cost on the bins and auger and tractor and trucks would be $0.30 per bushel. On top of that I would experience a lot of depreciation and property taxes and repairs.

bins would allow me to do a lot of things that I can’t do right now. A dryer would really be the thing that would make the biggest difference though and to do that I would get a couple of legs involved and buying more advantageous property and hauling further and so on. I bet I’d get $0.45 or more of opportunity cost into it.

Bags definitely have a fit. I can get 70% of the advantage of bins for probably 25% of the cost.

The good thing about bins though is that if you buy them and they’re big enough to be useful for another generation and the next generation decides to farm, the next generation can really benefit by using depreciated out bins for many years. When I get done farming I’ll just have a bunch of worn out bagging equipment and if another generation wants to farm they will have to decide what they are going to do.




Edited by dpilot83 11/17/2026 10:36
Top of the page Bottom of the page


Jump to forum :
Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread

(Delete cookies)