AgTalk Home
AgTalk Home
Search Forums | Classifieds (32) | Skins | Language
You are logged in as a guest. ( logon | register )

Humic results - side by side results years later?
View previous thread :: View next thread
   Forums List -> Crop TalkMessage format
 
easymoney
Posted 11/14/2026 05:33 (#11802152 - in reply to #11802058)
Subject: RE: Humic results - side by side results years later?


ecmn
Mark in WCIowa - 11/13/2026 21:04

What exactly WOULD you measure to see if a product gave you its money's worth?


We should and hold the product accountable for what it is. Not whether it creates a yield response.

We can apply nutrients and we have a lot of available testing and we are very familiar with applying a nutrient and measuring the soil. Plant, physically looking at the plant where we having a deficiency that the plant actually had a physical symptom that was talking to us and now we've corrected that...

If it's a soil amendment product, shouldn't we be checking the soil? You might be there with a shovel and you might be there with a magnifying glass. Compaction, infiltration, little micro aggregation improvements.. we can pull soil tests. We can pull plant tests. We can measure soil life. We can measure carbon and many things in the soil.

If it's a biological product. I'd send a sample out, find a lab that can test it and verify what the label says. Can anybody confirm that?

Just because we fix a nutrient deficiency, improve soil function , improve biology , improve nutrient cycling and availability in the soil ...doesn't guarantee us a yield response or profit.

I guess I'm a big believer in that early on while I'm trying to help improve my soil. Some biological, biological stimulants, humic fulvic soil amendment type products to help jump start the system have merit. With the goal being that at some point I will no longer need them.
The more carbon we start to build in the soil, the more biology we start to build the soil, the less I need to be buying carbon and biology. Then they start to cycle nutrients and I need to buy less nutrients...
Top of the page Bottom of the page


Jump to forum :
Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread

(Delete cookies)