AgTalk Home
AgTalk Home
Search Forums | Classifieds (18) | Skins | Language
You are logged in as a guest. ( logon | register )

Whats your experience with every other row Y drops ?
View previous thread :: View next thread
   Forums List -> Crop TalkMessage format
 
Ted2
Posted 2/6/2023 17:38 (#10081839)
Subject: Whats your experience with every other row Y drops ?


Northern Illinois
I'm looking at Ez drops for a JD 4710 90 ft .Ez Drops sells a kit for every row (32% on both sides of stalk) or every other row (32% one side of stalk). Have you seen any yield drop or application problems with every other row? I wil be applying 20 gallons more or less.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
mrbaer
Posted 2/6/2023 18:20 (#10081889 - in reply to #10081839)
Subject: RE: Whats your experience with every other row Y drops ?



Central Ill-Tremont
Works just fine
Top of the page Bottom of the page
mcgncoh
Posted 2/6/2023 18:52 (#10081953 - in reply to #10081839)
Subject: RE: Whats your experience with every other row Y drops ?


North Central Ohio
I've done it for years. Works great.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
dt4020
Posted 2/6/2023 18:52 (#10081955 - in reply to #10081839)
Subject: RE: Whats your experience with every other row Y drops ?


Fairbury, NE (Southeast)
excellent results with homemade.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
SilverClayON
Posted 2/6/2023 19:59 (#10082095 - in reply to #10081839)
Subject: RE: Whats your experience with every other row Y drops ?


SW Ontario
We apply skip row. Way I see it less surface area for volatilization to occur. Less drops hanging on boom and have had excellent success so far. We typically apply 20-40 gpa.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Hogsforever
Posted 2/6/2023 20:21 (#10082160 - in reply to #10081839)
Subject: RE: Whats your experience with every other row Y drops ?


N. Illinois
Have applied on 60” for years. The ez drops do a wonderful job of getting the nitrogen at the base of the plant. They need to sell wear tubes or something. This is after 1000 acres or so. I talked to them at ez drop and I knew they were going to say you’re running them to low. The are awesome for getting nitrogen where it needs to be but the jury is still out on longevity. I went and spent $30 on pex tubing and sleeved 18” chunks on each drop with a hose clamp



(B21C2D99-BE4F-46BE-A064-06468650E52B (full).jpeg)



Attachments
----------------
Attachments B21C2D99-BE4F-46BE-A064-06468650E52B (full).jpeg (85KB - 68 downloads)
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Bhrfarms
Posted 2/6/2023 20:38 (#10082186 - in reply to #10082160)
Subject: RE: Whats your experience with every other row Y drops ?


Northeast Indiana
I currently run 360 Ydrops instead of EZ Drops (Though I do think EZ Drops are a good system) and before the 360 Ydrops we ran C&R Supply's version. In both systems I've ran I've found we get the best placement with the base of the drop 14-20" off of the ground. I've found when I run really close to the ground, the hoses bounce around a whole lot more and don't just drag the tip right next the base of the plant like they do when at the proper height.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
SEIA
Posted 2/7/2023 08:19 (#10082669 - in reply to #10082186)
Subject: RE: Whats your experience with every other row Y drops ?


What was your experience like with the C&R supply drops? I'm looking at adding drops and that is one of the brands I'm looking at. Thanks
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Bhrfarms
Posted 2/7/2023 11:25 (#10082942 - in reply to #10082669)
Subject: RE: Whats your experience with every other row Y drops ?


Northeast Indiana
Compared to the 360 Ydrops, they are definitely inferior. Being light weight is very much a negative when side dressing with ydrops. The lighter weight C&R Supply ydrops bounce around and sway from side to side much more than the 360 ydrops. Due to the extra movement and the design of the C&R Supply ydrops, you don't get as consistent placement as you do with the 360 ydrops. Now if you only run 6mph its probably a little easier to keep them from moving around and hold the placement next to the row, but even at 10mph you get a lot of movement and the fertilizer placement just isn't as consistent. Can you get by with the C&R Supply ydrops? Yes, but they aren't as friendly to boom movement and there are definitely better options out there. For running every row on 60ft the 360 ydrops were about $8k more than the C&R Supply ydrops, that price difference is probably a little bit higher today. At $10k price difference on 1000 acres of corn you need less than 2bu to pay the difference. I can easily see that pay back from the better placement of the 360 ydrops in just 1 year. I know this thread is about only running on every other row, but for the extra cost, I think it is worth it to run every row. Just my opinion.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Jlbfarm
Posted 2/6/2023 20:51 (#10082219 - in reply to #10082160)
Subject: RE: Whats your experience with every other row Y drops ?


Colfax Indiana
2022 was my first year. I’m running every other row. Been working well. Have ez-drops. So Hogsforever
I got 700 acres on mine. Still look like new. Don’t look like yours. I’m running center puck 3-4 inches off ground
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Hogsforever
Posted 2/7/2023 07:46 (#10082617 - in reply to #10082219)
Subject: RE: Whats your experience with every other row Y drops ?


N. Illinois
Jlbfarm - 2/6/2023 20:51

2022 was my first year. I’m running every other row. Been working well. Have ez-drops. So Hogsforever
I got 700 acres on mine. Still look like new. Don’t look like yours. I’m running center puck 3-4 inches off ground



I too was running the puck 3-4” off the ground as best I could, not always easy in hills. We were pretty dry with hard ground also so maybe our ground was abrasive. Let the corn get a little taller so I could run the drops higher.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Patriot81
Posted 2/6/2023 21:19 (#10082268 - in reply to #10082160)
Subject: RE: Whats your experience with every other row Y drops ?


Farmington, Mo
Mine look similar after a 1000 acres as well. I believe they have a “high wear” kit if you wish to purchase…I did not.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
mij
Posted 2/6/2023 22:18 (#10082335 - in reply to #10081839)
Subject: RE: Whats your experience with every other row Y drops ?


SC, MN.
Assuming each side of the Y drop has its own supply hose & orfice, then Id go every other row. Less cost , less weight, quicker install / removal.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
cf1967
Posted 2/7/2023 06:56 (#10082551 - in reply to #10081839)
Subject: RE: Whats your experience with every other row Y drops ?


I had EZ Drops last year and was really impressed. They do a great job on staying between the row but still being flexible enough to not knock down corn or get broken if you run them into an object or the ground. I had C&R before that and the EZ Drops are much better. They are also very lightweight. Barely know they are on the boom
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Jump to forum :
Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread

(Delete cookies)