AgTalk Home
AgTalk Home
Search Forums | Classifieds (117) | Skins | Language
You are logged in as a guest. ( logon | register )

John Deere 4600 Display limitations?
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [50 messages per page]
View previous thread :: View next thread
   Forums List -> Precision TalkMessage format
 
gwagner
Posted 6/19/2017 22:32 (#6079903)
Subject: John Deere 4600 Display limitations?



This past spring we purchased a 2016 John Deere R Tractor with a 4600 display. We opted to install the full data record keeping software into the 4600.

First of all the 4600 display in my opinion is not ready for “big” time yet. Navigation and screen layouts are not very user friendly. Maybe other farmers have opinions that I would like to hear.

My comments are focused on the data collected. At the time we started recording the “as applied” data I didn’t realize that the data collected could not be loaded into Apex. All data MUST be loaded into the John Deere Operations Center. I was told by 1-800-GreenStar, rep, that Apex will not read 4600 data. It is a completely different data file format and Apex will not be updated to read this file structure.

I am not a big fan of loading farm data unto a server unless I WANT TO, not being forced to. As we go forward, the new John Deere sprayers, combines, and planters will all operate with the 4600 (4640) display. It looks like if you are a Deere customer and want to purchase the newer technology they offer they are going to get our data if we like it or not. So much for being a "open data" company

Now some will say; “In the operation center, you can opt out sharing data”, this is true, but they put strict limitations on the data analysis you can view. Guess I didn't read the fine print before I purchased the new tractor and "MOTHER" deere knows better than I do.

Nothing like being between a rock and hard place.

Any thoughts?

Gary


Edited by gwagner 6/19/2017 22:43
Top of the page Bottom of the page
cyclones30
Posted 6/19/2017 22:58 (#6079949 - in reply to #6079903)
Subject: RE: John Deere 4600 Display limitations?



Midwest
You're correct on Apex not reading the new data. I would venture to guess SMS and others will eventually be able to deal with the data. It always takes a little time after release for the 3rd party programs to catch up.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Rossf93
Posted 6/20/2017 03:41 (#6080013 - in reply to #6079903)
Subject: RE: John Deere 4600 Display limitations?


just my 2 cents

i would beg to differ on the navigational use of the new screen, very easy to use and can all be operated from a single screen, job, map, farm, field, client, swap track, machine width, work setup, this is just the usual thing of resistance to change, initially i felt exactly the same way but after some use i have found to the screen to be very much the opposite and it poses much more processing power for future use,

yes the apex thing could be somewhat of an issue but apex is a prehistoric system and has nothing but complaints for ease of use. listening to the comments about SMS etc i agree that a simple single userface would be more useful but at the end of the day John Deere is a business much like apple etc, you will not see apple and microsoft working together to gain business for both parties, although probably not a huge advantage to most, the operations center already allows compatibility with Ag Leader Versa™, Integra™, and Compass™ displays so in time id expect more usability.

the big picture with the operations center is for a easier more connected solution, allowing agronomists, dealers, anyone who can aid your business access to the data without having to get it hardwired via usb. this works both ways with you being able to send jobs instantaneously through this one system not having to bounce betwen, jdlink, ape and MJD...it is trying to transition to a much smoother workflow, the 4600 & 4640 both upload information to the cloud in real time allowing for managers and farmers to see the job as its happening. if this isn't for you, you can freely turn syncing off and upload the data via the trusty old USB via the upload manager program available on the site whenever you desire, keep as many files as you want and only upload which you'd prefer or require.

what functionality do you use currently that you would like to see in either the 4600 or MJD operations center?
Top of the page Bottom of the page
GOOSEPILOT
Posted 6/20/2017 07:29 (#6080227 - in reply to #6079903)
Subject: RE: John Deere 4600 Display limitations?


WC Mn/Dakotas
...
Top of the page Bottom of the page
McFlyAg
Posted 6/20/2017 09:22 (#6080393 - in reply to #6080013)
Subject: RE: John Deere 4600 Display limitations?


Ross93,

I would be cautious to use the phrase "this is just the usual thing of resistance to change". While I am certain that resistance to change can leave a distaste with many users, I think it is important to consider that a new layout may not actually be better. I feel that JD was attempting to make this have a similar feel as an iPad without completely copying their design, kind of like the same way college students copy a paragraph into their paper and change a couple words to avoid plagiarism. While I like the customization of a couple things on the 4600 and the ability to have more options on the run screen, I tend to find myself searching for what I need a lot more, even after working with them very often. Another issue is the amount of confirmation notices that are displayed; select a field "are you sure? > ok" click on A+ "are you sure? > ok" open the door of the machine "are you sure you want to get out? > ok". These extra steps and the amount of customization could make it difficult for dealers to support a user over the phone due to displays not being as standard as the previous displays, but with the ability for RDA and the onscreen help, I think most will be okay.

The 4600 is not ready for the "big time" yet, but with the 4640 and the 4600 being nearly identical in operating system and hardware, I think we will see giant leaps in functionality in the next few software releases.

As for the data portion of Gary's post, I think what he is getting at is that he does not want to pass off his data to another party with the hopes that they will keep it safe and never use it for malicious intent. Just this week we saw the RNC leak over a terabyte of data consisting of more than 200 million peoples information. If you are someone, as I am sure Gary is, who has data going back to the 90's and value it like gold, I would not want to "trust" that a multi-billion dollar company is going to do their best to keep it private and not collect data from it. Right now though, I believe the only option is to upload, let it process, and export as .shp? Or just store them until another software company is able to interpret the data properly. It will be interesting to see how non-JD companies handle the ActiveYield data from new combines...

Top of the page Bottom of the page
torn
Posted 6/20/2017 09:57 (#6080431 - in reply to #6079903)
Subject: RE: John Deere 4600 Display limitations?


roaming
gwagner - 6/19/2017 21:32
Now some will say; “In the operation center, you can opt out sharing data”, this is true, but they put strict limitations on the data analysis you can view. Guess I didn't read the fine print before I purchased the new tractor and "MOTHER" deere knows better than I do.

I'm not disagreeing with anything you said, but let me play the Devil's advocate:
If you HAD read the fine print, would it have made a difference in your purchase decision? Or are you just saying that you wish there had been full disclosure up front, even though you would have made the same decision?
Top of the page Bottom of the page
gwagner
Posted 6/20/2017 10:40 (#6080489 - in reply to #6080431)
Subject: Full Disclosure



You are right; I probably would have made the same decision on purchasing the tractor. BUT I had the option to use a 2630 to record my “as applied” data and not unlock the “as applied” codes in the 4600. When my dealer didn’t realize that 4600 data could not be read by Apex, until I told him yesterday, something is not right. Once the codes are entered in the 4600, I am told they cannot be transferred.
The reason I posted this thread is to let other farmer know what will happen if you purchase a 4600, I went into it blind.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
4wdaaron
Posted 6/20/2017 10:46 (#6080497 - in reply to #6079903)
Subject: RE: John Deere 4600 Display limitations?


Northern Indiana
Four calendar years the Gen 4 has been on the armrest of 8R tractors and they still don't have it figured out. For every one one good thing there's about five bad things. Doing some particular things take 30-150% more button presses than before.

Sure wish we could put 2630 software on the Gen 4 hardware

Edited by 4wdaaron 6/20/2017 10:46
Top of the page Bottom of the page
gwagner
Posted 6/20/2017 10:50 (#6080500 - in reply to #6080013)
Subject: RE: John Deere 4600 Display limitations?



I agree the 4600 display has a lot to offer. Here is what I do not like about the display;

  1. It was originally designed for tractor monitoring. Not for record keeping (the 2630 was designed for record keeping and navigation). In my opinion this was an afterthought in the 4600
  2. Equipment measurements and other information cannot be imported from Apex. Since the 4600 display calculates equipment measurement differently all of this needs to be redone.
  3. Key strokes (presses on the screen) are EXTREMELY non user friendly. Navigating to desired setup screens, field information, navigation, products, etc. Takes 6,7,8 key strokes
  4. A major bug that Deere has not fixed yet. In Rate Controller, if you make any equipment changes, this over writes the Equipment measurements. I found this out the hard way.
  5. I use 2 Raven chemical injection units on my sprayer, (found out JD at this time allows the use of, but does not support it), under certain circumstances would flip the chem injection units. This could have been serious because I was using 2oz of one chemical and 32oz of another.
  6. Another feature not working yet(the 4600 has been out several years) AB curve track. In the 2630 with a curve track you can center yourself when using different size equipment. With the 4600 you have to shift track yourself until you are centered. The centering option is greyed out.
  7. 1-800-GREENSTAR support. Non-existent!! Called numerous times for clarification. No one on the front line could help (all they could do is bring up a simulator). I asked to be bumped up to the next level. The answer I got that he was on another line. Asked if I could get a call back, the answer was, “sorry we don’t do that”.

So far MJD is much like Apex (and I agree Apex needs to go away), doesn’t allow editing of application entries. I made a mistake and entered 6 floz on a herbicide application, that I applied 4 floz. This can be serious when it is on someone else’s server, especially if it was off label.

The next post is what I like

Top of the page Bottom of the page
rollig
Posted 6/21/2017 12:14 (#6082392 - in reply to #6080500)
Subject: RE: John Deere 4600 Display limitations?


SCMN

You guys are making me feel better about buying new 2630's this spring instead of waiting for a 4640 universal option.  

Top of the page Bottom of the page
earp
Posted 6/24/2017 10:10 (#6087522 - in reply to #6079903)
Subject: RE: John Deere 4600 Display limitations?



Manila, Ar
JD keeps trying to make this too complicated..........most of the functions have very little value to me, and I'm only running armrest monitors and 2630 screens.......I still like the old brown box, it was simple and didn't offer a lot variations, and it was and still is all i needed......:)
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [50 messages per page]
Jump to forum :
Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread

(Delete cookies)