|
|
| See Monsanto is testing soil and seed innoculants
Any body using Sabrex quick roots studies
Edited by old boy 1/8/2016 12:37
|
|
| |
|
| I have used quick roots on soybeans side by side weigh wagon 2 different fields 2 1/2 -2 3/4 bushel increase using the stuff verses straight inoculant. Will put on more acres this year. Did not try it on corn. |
|
| |
|
northeastern Ohio | Here is a corn plot from 2015 in Winchester, IL that was done by Prairieland FS: http://www.prairielandfs.com/agronomy/Documents/2015%20plots/Winche...
Force + Starter: 171.1
Starter: 177.25
Force + Starter + Sabrex: 184.16
Starter + Sabrex: 185.6
Force + Sabrex: 175.7
Sabrex: 177.0
Here is another one they did at another location this year: http://www.prairielandfs.com/agronomy/Documents/2015%20plots/Adams_...
Dkc62-08 with Sabrex: 230 bu
Dkc62-08: 224 bu
Here's one from Minnesota: http://kunerthseedcenter.com/WordPress/wp-content/uploads/2013/11/T...
DKC48-12 with Sabrex: 217.5
DKC48-12: 213.6
Edited by Jay NE Ohio 1/8/2016 07:33
|
|
| |
|
Southeast WI | Prairieland had something good going there but they didn't have a zero anything plot. Also after opening the link and looking that wasn't a good plot - it wasn't really replicated as I don't understand why it was set up that way. And do you see the bounce between same treatments? You can't get any info out of that plot. |
|
| |
|
NW IL | I have used it in 2 different years across multiply hybrids. Always split the planter. The results are always the same here 0 to 2 bu decrease. They have asked me to try it again next year. I'm expecting they will owe me and the wife a steak dinner this time when it doesn't perform.
You'll have to throw the 5989 out of the trial, because if you look at the acres it was not replicated evenly.
Edited by 9670guy 1/8/2016 08:47
 (IMG_0474.JPG)
Attachments
----------------
 IMG_0474.JPG (113KB - 173 downloads)
|
|
| |
|
NC Iowa | Tried sabrex split planted over 80 acres and the results were the same as 9670. If you want to read some interesting articles google "corn root sloughing". Just because a plant has bigger roots does not mean that it will increase yield, there are many benefits of sloughing roots. |
|
| |
|
| Same results here just like a 2 cylinder John Deere hit and miss !!! |
|
| |
|
northeastern Ohio | Pvafarm - 1/8/2016 07:38
Prairieland had something good going there but they didn't have a zero anything plot. Also after opening the link and looking that wasn't a good plot - it wasn't really replicated as I don't understand why it was set up that way. And do you see the bounce between same treatments? You can't get any info out of that plot.
I am not going to question their methods because I don't know any more about the plot than what is in the link. If I average the "no Sabrex" treatments against the "Sabrex" treatments, I see a 6.4 bushel advantage to the Sabrex treatments. Alone, that plot may not be valid, but when you combine with the other two plots I posted, they average 5.5 bushel gain with the Sabrex. That is pretty consistent with what I have seen in the plots over the past 7 years. |
|
| |
|
| We (On Farm Network) have done a handful of Quickroots trials in Iowa in 2012 & 2015. Like others have said pretty mixed results.
The link below shows the results. Selecting "Trial Summary" to the right will display the details of the individual trials.
http://www.isafarmnet.com/onlinedb/?year%5B%5D=all&crop%5B%5D=all&t...
Thanks |
|
| |
|
NW Illinois Stephenson county | You better tune up your 2 cylinder...just saying or maybe get the carb rebuilt. |
|
| |
|
Southeast MN | Have tried Sabrex, Quickroots, Ascend, Torque and challenge 2050. In field trials across many acres. Bigger roots, yes. More yield, No.
However I do have customers that use quickroots and have had success. |
|
| |
|
Lancaster, OH | This is a product we released last year. These are from 3rd party researchers in replicated testing including private and university researchers. More information is on the link below but I won't "sell" anymore than present this information which will be released shortly.
Take Off ST seed treatment comparisons against no Take Off ST. Fungicides/insecticide consistent between comparisons.
Corn, 7 states, two years, 3 bushels average w/62% wins. Average win 7.5 bushels
Spring Wheat, 4 states, two years, 1.5 bushels, 67% wins. Average win 2.9 bushels.
Winter Wheat, 10 states, two years, 2.3 bushels, 67% wins. Average win 4.3 bushels.
Soybeans, 7 states, two years, 1.1 bushels, 78% wins. Average win 2 bushels (no inoculant)
Just finished compiling the 2015 data. Overall, seed treatments had less impact in 2015 than in 2014 across the US. Some areas still had consistent increases, others not so much. As a group, the instance of positive response and the magnitude was less. These results span 2014 & 2015 and averages for both years.
http://www.vlsci.com/products/seed-treatments-inoculants/take-off-s...
|
|
| |
|
CIL | for us....quickroots=snake oil. Absolutely no difference in yield despite trying it in the same field across several varieties. I'm glad we didn't have to pay for it. |
|
| |
|
| JimmyP - 1/8/2016 16:44 This is a product we released last year. These are from 3rd party researchers in replicated testing including private and university researchers. More information is on the link below but I won't "sell" anymore than present this information which will be released shortly. Take Off ST seed treatment comparisons against no Take Off ST. Fungicides/insecticide consistent between comparisons. Corn, 7 states, two years, 3 bushels average w/62% wins. Average win 7.5 bushels Spring Wheat, 4 states, two years, 1.5 bushels, 67% wins. Average win 2.9 bushels. Winter Wheat, 10 states, two years, 2.3 bushels, 67% wins. Average win 4.3 bushels. Soybeans, 7 states, two years, 1.1 bushels, 78% wins. Average win 2 bushels (no inoculant ) Just finished compiling the 2015 data. Overall, seed treatments had less impact in 2015 than in 2014 across the US. Some areas still had consistent increases, others not so much. As a group, the instance of positive response and the magnitude was less. These results span 2014 & 2015 and averages for both years. http://www.vlsci.com/products/seed-treatments-inoculants/take-off-s... Thank you for the candor! The gains seem quite meager -- does it even pay for the cost of the product? |
|
| |
How are the results for Sabrex and quick roots and others
