AgTalk Home
AgTalk Home
Search Forums | Classifieds (53) | Skins | Language
You are logged in as a guest. ( logon | register )

Grain Sorghum costs compared to Corn
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [50 messages per page]
View previous thread :: View next thread
   Forums List -> Market TalkMessage format
 
zenfarm
Posted 8/10/2015 16:31 (#4726082)
Subject: Grain Sorghum costs compared to Corn


South central kansas



Earlier in the year there was a lot of discussion about Sorghum vs Corn and some were going to plant some Sorghum because of the price differential and because of the lower cost. The following article looks at kansas farm management data and compares the two cost wise over time.




 

 

Agricultural Economic Insights

Perspectives of Two Agricultural Economists

 

<form id="searchform" style="border: 0px; font-family: inherit; font-style: inherit; font-weight: inherit; margin: 0px; outline: 0px; padding: 0px; vertical-align: baseline; position: absolute; top: 3.8em; right: 76px; text-align: right;" action="http://ageconomists.com/" method="get">

Main menu

 Previous 

Has a Cost of Production Advantage for Sorghum Emerged?

sorghum.cop

by David A. Widmar

In several previous posts we’ve taken a look at the trends and excitement surrounding sorghum. From historic production to yield trends and the emergence of a sorghum premium[1], we’ve covered a wide spectrum of topics. In this week’s post we take a look at the cost of production trends for sorghum over time.

 

K-State Budget Data

Taking a look at the Kansas State University crop budgets for the South Central region, changes in the primary variable input expenses for sorghum and corn were evaluated, figure 1. Primary variable inputs included seed, herbicide, insecticide, and fertilizer/lime.

In general, the trends for the two crops appear very similar. Both have the expenses increasing over time with a sharp spike in 2009. A closer look at the data, however, shows that the primary inputs for corn (blue) increased at a faster rate than sorghum (orange). This is illustrated with the trend lines. For sorghum, primary inputs increased $4.77/acre per year while increasing $8.31/acre per year for corn. Over the 15 year period, this difference in annual change resulted in corn variable costs increasing $53 per acre more than sorghum.

To look at the changes in another way we compared the expenses across two time periods. The average of the expense from 2001-2005 was compared to the average of the expense from the 2011-2015 period. For sorghum, the primary input expenses increased 73% from 2001-2005 to 2011-2015 while corn increased 88%.

Sorghum Cost of Production. Corn. Kansas. Ag Trends. Agricultural Economic Insights

Figure 1. Budgeted Expense for Primary Inputs (Seed, Fertilizer, Herbicide, and Insecticide) for Corn and Sorghum in South Central Kansas. 2001-2015. Data Source: Kansas State University/AgManager.info.

Wrapping it Up

Recent years have seen renewed optimism in sorghum.  After decades of declining acres and slow gains in yields, recent excitement about the crop was met by strong prices. Subtly a cost of production advantage for sorghum also appears to have been developing.

While the cost of production for both sorghum and corn has been increasing in recent years, sorghum costs have not increased as significantly.When looking at the budgets for the variable inputs (seed, fertilizer/lime, herbicide, and insecticide), costs in South Central Kansas increased at a slower rate for sorghum. Over 15 years the impacts became substantial.

As we mentioned with earlier posts, producers should carefully consider their unique situation and evaluate how significant and sustainable they believe any economic advantages sorghum may generate for their operation.

Interested in learning more? Follow the Agricultural Economic Insights’ Blog by clicking here. Also, follow AEI on Twitter and Facebook.

 

[1] It’s worth noting that much of the sorghum premium quickly evaporated earlier this year.  However, sorghum basis is still stronger (higher) than in 2014 and the average from 2004-2013. Furthermore, the basis gap between sorghum and corn (sorghum basis less corn basis) has recently favored corn but not as much as in the past. So while sorghum cash prices are currently less attractive than earlier in 2015, they are still above historic expectations.

 

Photo Source: Flickr/USDA



Edited by zenfarm 8/10/2015 16:32
Top of the page Bottom of the page
jblands
Posted 8/10/2015 17:01 (#4726119 - in reply to #4726082)
Subject: RE: Grain Sorghum costs compared to Corn


For me there is a third reason for milo, pigweeds. Roundup just doesn't kill any pigweeds for me anymore. Tried Liberty this year. It was better but not nearly 100%. With an +.85 basis over December corn earlier this year, lower cost of production than corn and better weed control than beans, milo was the crop to grow this year. It may be totally different next year. I might add that the last 10 days has taken a bite out of my profit on milo. I sprayed for corn earworms last week and have the sivanto on hand for sugarcane aphids. This will add at least $50/ac to the cost of production.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
McHusker
Posted 8/10/2015 17:33 (#4726159 - in reply to #4726119)
Subject: RE: Grain Sorghum costs compared to Corn


Nebraska aka the boondocks
add hellfire to your roundup
Top of the page Bottom of the page
jblands
Posted 8/10/2015 17:50 (#4726198 - in reply to #4726159)
Subject: RE: Grain Sorghum costs compared to Corn


Never heard of it. I looked it up on the Helena website. May try it next year.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
McHusker
Posted 8/10/2015 18:05 (#4726224 - in reply to #4726198)
Subject: RE: Grain Sorghum costs compared to Corn


Nebraska aka the boondocks
I started using in 06 or 07, can't remember. You can heat up the roundup to the point it will whack your crops. I generally use 2.5 gallons per 1000 over the top and 5 to 7 gallons per 1000 on burndown. Sprayed some pigweed on end of beans two days ago, and were leaning the next day.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Jim1_ks
Posted 8/10/2015 18:13 (#4726241 - in reply to #4726082)
Subject: RE: Grain Sorghum costs compared to Corn



South Central Kansas, Harper County
Kevin.
For me, the cost of chemical and fertilizer are just about the same for corn or milo. The seed cost is cheaper for milo than corn, and currantly the milo price is higher than corn. Plus, it has been a lot easier for me to grow 100 bu milo than 100 bu corn. I do like corn, as it is easy to get back into wheat, and comes off earlier than milo, and hence doesnt use up as much moisture if going back to wheat. Now, we are going to spray for aphids for the first time in milo, so that is an added expense that I havent had in the past.
Jim
Top of the page Bottom of the page
zenfarm
Posted 8/10/2015 19:20 (#4726346 - in reply to #4726241)
Subject: RE: Grain Sorghum costs compared to Corn


South central kansas

Yes, Jim, having tried Corn in the past, I agree with your statements, but none the less thought it was interesting to see the data over time, between the two. With all the earlier discussion on milo on NAT it will be interesting to see how much of an increase in acres their is.



 The graph below shows sorghum acres and bushels of production in the U.S. since 1929. Up until the late 1950s, acres of sorghum planted increased over time; peaking in 1957 at nearly 27 million acres. Sorghum production, measured in bushels, peaked in 1985 at 1,120 million bushels of production.

sorghum3



Edited by zenfarm 8/10/2015 19:24
Top of the page Bottom of the page
sckansas
Posted 8/10/2015 21:31 (#4726681 - in reply to #4726241)
Subject: RE: Grain Sorghum costs compared to Corn


eastern south central KS
I'm about 90 mi. NE of you Jim; not much swing back to milo here, but then we have better ave. prec. and heavier soils. No question that seed is the biggest cost difference between the two crops. I like a rotation that is corn-wheat-double-crop beans and then back to corn. Milo can come off late and of course the allopathic effect on the wheat is not helpful. Something about a wheat-corn rotation seems to be beneficial to corn yields; cutting the double crop beans deals with stubble tho' often one is lucky to get his investment back on dbcr. beans. Occasionally one is able to really make out on the bean end.... last year with great Sept. rains and an extended growing season we were able to achieve 30 bu. yields. 12-20 is more the norm.

Somehow its hard for me to go back to milo; just like to all around timing of corn and the showiness of the crop. Strip Till has really helped us deal with early planting and establishing a good stand.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Jim1_ks
Posted 8/11/2015 07:30 (#4727160 - in reply to #4726681)
Subject: RE: Grain Sorghum costs compared to Corn



South Central Kansas, Harper County
sckansas - 8/10/2015 21:31

I'm about 90 mi. NE of you Jim; not much swing back to milo here, but then we have better ave. prec. and heavier soils. No question that seed is the biggest cost difference between the two crops. I like a rotation that is corn-wheat-double-crop beans and then back to corn. Milo can come off late and of course the allopathic effect on the wheat is not helpful. Something about a wheat-corn rotation seems to be beneficial to corn yields; cutting the double crop beans deals with stubble tho' often one is lucky to get his investment back on dbcr. beans. Occasionally one is able to really make out on the bean end.... last year with great Sept. rains and an extended growing season we were able to achieve 30 bu. yields. 12-20 is more the norm.

Somehow its hard for me to go back to milo; just like to all around timing of corn and the showiness of the crop. Strip Till has really helped us deal with early planting and establishing a good stand.[/QUOTE
That should put you somewhere perhaps in Butler County? I agree with all you've said about more precip(normally) and very good dirt in your area, for sure. So, with your rotation, is wheat just a 1 year crop? And, also curious, are beans planted only in DC situations? Corn is your "bell cow" crop, so to speak?
Top of the page Bottom of the page
sckansas
Posted 8/11/2015 08:11 (#4727231 - in reply to #4727160)
Subject: RE: Grain Sorghum costs compared to Corn


eastern south central KS
Yes, wheat is a one year crop mostly for me. Still have full season beans, but having real issues with pigweed that is resistant to everything we throw at it. Weed control is heavy wheat stubble seems to be much easier. I am in northwestern Butler Co. as you correctly guessed.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [50 messages per page]
Jump to forum :
Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread

(Delete cookies)