AgTalk Home
AgTalk Home
Search Forums | Classifieds (41) | Skins | Language
You are logged in as a guest. ( logon | register )

Bale baron or hay accumulators and grapples?
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [50 messages per page]
View previous thread :: View next thread
   Forums List -> Machinery TalkMessage format
 
Jhayes
Posted 4/2/2015 21:39 (#4493035)
Subject: Bale baron or hay accumulators and grapples?


Hey guys we are a family farm from Ontario we currently do about 7000 small square hay bales and 5000 straw bales. We moved to a new holland stacker last year and works really well, but still enough work to load trailers or semi's once it's in the barn it's getting to be just me and my dad. I need to make it easier for me and him I want to be in the business for a long time, I just would like some thoughts on what route to go I really like the bale baron but the cost of it seems high compared to other options. I plan to be at 20000 bales a year by 2016

Thanks
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Slugbait
Posted 4/2/2015 22:48 (#4493189 - in reply to #4493035)
Subject: RE: Bale baron or hay accumulators and grapples?



Pedee, Oregon
Any chance you could use a hay squeeze? I load in and out with a grapple, but at that volume it would be a bottleneck. Beats throwing bales by hand though. What size bales are you making? 2 wide or 3 wide with the stacker?
Top of the page Bottom of the page
twraska
Posted 4/2/2015 22:48 (#4493190 - in reply to #4493035)
Subject: RE: Bale baron or hay accumulators and grapples?


Wallis, TX

We had a Steffen system, sold it and said if we ever wanted to get into the small square market again, we'd to the Bale Baron.  We did bale some for a guy who came in with his Baron and bundled up our bales for us.

Steffen is cheaper, you can stack and unstack but is slow and the end user (feed store) can't benefit from it unless they have a grapple.

Bale Baron is EXPEN$IVE but the feed store can use a forklift to move the 21  bale stacks.  Sometimes you can sell hay just on this point.

Cons, either one, the bales must be consistent in size or you'll have a jam up.  Baron will either jam or cut the end off the long bale then you have a busted bale in the bundle.  Hard to get heavy bales in the Baron as they can't be longer than 36" (about 32" string to string), we did have some customers complain about light bales.  And these are 'horse' customers who rarely complain about light bales.  We had the Steffen behind the baler and you had to slow the baler down to get the 'perfect' bales for it.  Same was true for the Baron but it was being pulled by a separate tractor so if the baler busted a bale he just went around it.  When the machine is pulled by the baler and the baler misses a tie, you have two problems to fix.  The baler and the subsequent choke up in the accumulator.

In short, either one will pay for themselves thru labor savings but there are hidden costs in owning one.

Top of the page Bottom of the page
collegefarmer
Posted 4/2/2015 23:03 (#4493216 - in reply to #4493035)
Subject: RE: Bale baron or hay accumulators and grapples?


A little background info before my thoughts...

2013- we put up ~2500 squares with 1 baler using a 10 bale push type accumulator in front of a skid steer and a grapple on skid steer to load/unload trailers. This worked ok, but the time spent accumulating/stacking/unloading really limited our productivity.

2014- Upgraded to a late model baler, added Kuhns 1036F (10 bale) accumulator, and added a 510F tie grabber. Also added some part time labor. We put the tie grabber on a loader tractor and stacked in the field and used the skid steer to unload at the barn. This system worked WAY better than the previous, the most our 3 man crew was able to put up was 2300/day and ended up with ~15,000 bales made in 2014.

2015- For I have added another baler/1534 Kuhns, traded the 1036F for a 1534, and a few other misc. things. We are planning on making around 25k-30k bales in 2015 and would like to see 4k-5k bales/day with a 4 man crew.

I'm not sure what your weather patterns are like up there, but we can have very short windows for putting up dry hay and reasonably long windows depending on the year. In short, less time demands more machinery.

My thoughts on it are, if we add a third baler (45k-50k bales) that will about be the tipping point between accumulators and bundlers. The amount of $ in the accumulator system will be similar to the bundlers, but more operators needed. But, I would be seriously considering going to big squares at that point too.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
slowzuki
Posted 4/3/2015 08:12 (#4493600 - in reply to #4493035)
Subject: RE: Bale baron or hay accumulators and grapples?


New Brunswick, Canada
Do you have a matching grapple to be able to handle your stacks with a tractor? Steffen make them. Depending on model of bale wagon you can load semi's from ground level with a cardinal slide/contraption rig or build your own.

Jhayes - 4/2/2015 21:39

Hey guys we are a family farm from Ontario we currently do about 7000 small square hay bales and 5000 straw bales. We moved to a new holland stacker last year and works really well, but still enough work to load trailers or semi's once it's in the barn it's getting to be just me and my dad. I need to make it easier for me and him I want to be in the business for a long time, I just would like some thoughts on what route to go I really like the bale baron but the cost of it seems high compared to other options. I plan to be at 20000 bales a year by 2016

Thanks
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Larry in AB
Posted 4/3/2015 10:27 (#4493925 - in reply to #4493035)
Subject: RE: Bale baron or hay accumulators and grapples?


Alberta, Canada

I make lots of small squares and there is a big industry of export hay in sm. squares in Alberta. The method "here" for large volumes of squares is using NH self propelled stackers for picking them in a timely manner. For loading trucks a bale head on a loader that picks up a full tier off the stack of 18 bales on a tractor or some use zoom booms which are handy for van trailers/containers. You can do lots with on of them baleheads as for sorting hay and restacking the stacks. I have a friend who bought one so just he could utilize some lower hay sheds he couldn't stack in with his nh balewagon. Plus you can loader trailers, some bale heads are made to spin 180 to load from teh side of the trailer.

Not sure where your market is or if you do enough volume yet but adding a retriever truck is another handy tool as again here everyone ones it delivered. I also use the retrierver truck to bring stacks into the sheds from distant fields as roading with the NH balewagon takes too much time. Espeically when you're dodging thunder storms!

Below a truck is moving hay from field to sheds or sometimes directly to stables.

Next pic is the bale head on the tractor.  Now that tractor is a bit small or I guess the loader is a bit small/light as it doesn't quite lift high enough on some stacks. It works and we've used it alot but I'd like a higher lift loader.  Better would be say a 100hp tractor with a decent sized loader.



Edited by Larry in AB 4/3/2015 11:05




(IMG_0253.JPG)



(bale head.jpg)



Attachments
----------------
Attachments IMG_0253.JPG (109KB - 566 downloads)
Attachments bale head.jpg (131KB - 578 downloads)
Top of the page Bottom of the page
jcfarmboy
Posted 4/3/2015 11:01 (#4494014 - in reply to #4493035)
Subject: RE: Bale baron or hay accumulators and grapples?



South Western Ontario, Canada
My friend just bought a bale baron last fall. He has one or both grapples and accumulator for sale. Great lakes in talbotville has them. On kijiji.

His biggest problem is the moving. Can grab eight at a time with grapple and 21 with the bale baron. Stacking in the barns is the bottleneck (and finding help). Nice thing with bale baron is you can still cut the bundle open for the guys that show up looking for small amounts at a time.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
RodInNS
Posted 4/3/2015 17:45 (#4494739 - in reply to #4493035)
Subject: RE: Bale baron or hay accumulators and grapples?


I think a grab that will handle the tiers from your bale wagon would be appropriate at this point... Accumulators have their place. I have an 18 bale Kuhns that works fairly well... but there is a lot of logistics to hauling away any amount of hay with that system. If you can haul the hay off now with what you have I think I'd stick to that. As far as Bale Barron's go... I think the idea has merit. I just don't see how it can work in terms of cost.

Rod
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [50 messages per page]
Jump to forum :
Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread

(Delete cookies)