AgTalk Home
AgTalk Home
Search Forums | Classifieds (113) | Skins | Language
You are logged in as a guest. ( logon | register )

Tell me the difference between auto antifreeze and plumbing antifreeze
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [50 messages per page]
View previous thread :: View next thread
   Forums List -> Machinery TalkMessage format
 
Gambler
Posted 11/7/2013 06:47 (#3429480)
Subject: Tell me the difference between auto antifreeze and plumbing antifreeze


need to get my sprayer winterized have in the past been able to get used antifreeze from a guy that does maintance on gensets stuff was just like new non available this year
Whats the diffrence between auto antifreeze and plumbing antifreeze the plumbing antifreeze is on sale -50
is it safer around pets ?

are new antifreezes still a dog killer

thanks
Top of the page Bottom of the page
salexmo
Posted 11/7/2013 06:52 (#3429492 - in reply to #3429480)
Subject: Re: Tell me the difference between auto antifreeze and plumbing antifreeze



northwest missouri
I always use the RV antifreeze, watch for it to go on sale in early fall and usually costs 2.50 - 3.00 @ gallon
Top of the page Bottom of the page
MCatSHF
Posted 11/7/2013 07:01 (#3429516 - in reply to #3429480)
Subject: RE: Tell me the difference between auto antifreeze and plumbing antifreeze



Sandy Hook, MB

Hello Gambler

Most new auto antifreeze has Bitrex in them to keep your pets & children from drinking them.

Top of the page Bottom of the page
gene_champ
Posted 11/7/2013 07:05 (#3429526 - in reply to #3429480)
Subject: RE: Tell me the difference between auto antifreeze and plumbing antifreeze


NC Iowa
plumbers antifreeze is probably propylene glycol, which in not poisonous like ethylene glycol.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
shaun3480
Posted 11/7/2013 07:19 (#3429565 - in reply to #3429480)
Subject: Re: Tell me the difference between auto antifreeze and plumbing antifreeze


Phillips Co NW Kansas
Rv anti freeze is bio degradeable. That is what I would use.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
glensts
Posted 11/7/2013 07:23 (#3429577 - in reply to #3429480)
Subject: Re: Tell me the difference between auto antifreeze and plumbing antifreeze



windshield washer cheaper? or do you guys get -40 washer fluid down south too?
Top of the page Bottom of the page
E718
Posted 11/7/2013 08:00 (#3429695 - in reply to #3429480)
Subject: Re: Tell me the difference between auto antifreeze and plumbing antifreeze


Sac & Story county IA
Is there a difference between RV anti freeze and boiler anti freeze? Both are propylene glycol, right? Anti corrosion shouldn't be a factor for my use. Only polyethylene and stainless, so not any dissimilar metals to bother.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
twraska
Posted 11/7/2013 08:11 (#3429725 - in reply to #3429577)
Subject: Re: Tell me the difference between auto antifreeze and plumbing antifreeze


Wallis, TX

I'd bet if I went into NAPA this morning, I'd still be getting 32F washer fluid.

Top of the page Bottom of the page
gene_champ
Posted 11/7/2013 08:13 (#3429732 - in reply to #3429695)
Subject: Re: Tell me the difference between auto antifreeze and plumbing antifreeze


NC Iowa
E718 - 11/7/2013 08:00

Is there a difference between RV anti freeze and boiler anti freeze? Both are propylene glycol, right? Anti corrosion shouldn't be a factor for my use. Only polyethylene and stainless, so not any dissimilar metals to bother.


i think rv antifreeze is alcohol based. you can get it for around $3 a gal. propylene glycol boiler anitfreeze like cryotek is about $17 a gal, so must be a difference.

http://www.menards.com/main/heating-cooling/hvac-cleaners/cryo-tek-...

Top of the page Bottom of the page
wctyilfarmer
Posted 11/7/2013 08:18 (#3429748 - in reply to #3429732)
Subject: Re: Tell me the difference between auto antifreeze and plumbing antifreeze


so il
what about methanol added to water, 2 parts water 1 part methanol should be -20 degrees.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
scott nelsen
Posted 11/7/2013 08:31 (#3429774 - in reply to #3429748)
Subject: Re: Tell me the difference between auto antifreeze and plumbing antifreeze


Leeds, North Dakota
When I built my shop with floor heat, didn't think much about plumbing antifreeze, was around when the plumber was filling system, asked him what kind of antifreeze is it, designed for floor heat, mfg of boiler required this or no warranty, 15 dollars a gallon, almost fell over, Scott.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
PeteMN
Posted 11/7/2013 08:43 (#3429809 - in reply to #3429774)
Subject: Re: Tell me the difference between auto antifreeze and plumbing antifreeze


E.Central MN
And you should be testing the water for the boiler every year, something I didn't know until I talked to an outdoor wood boiler guy. I guess it makes sense, its basically a big radiator with a heating unit made out of metal that corrodes over time.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
E718
Posted 11/7/2013 09:38 (#3429891 - in reply to #3429732)
Subject: Re: Tell me the difference between auto antifreeze and plumbing antifreeze


Sac & Story county IA
Here is an ad for RV anti freeze at HD. Says Propylene glycol based formula

I have been around water heating at a church with 60 year old system and the town water is terrible. I have seen dissimilar metal problems. And a lot of failures. I think I have those problems solved.

I am the designer, builder, owner, no warranty involved. Plumbers boat payment, either.

Top of the page Bottom of the page
durallymax
Posted 11/7/2013 12:42 (#3430150 - in reply to #3429480)
Subject: Re: Tell me the difference between auto antifreeze and plumbing antifreeze


Wi
Auto antifreeze is almost all Ethylene Glycol based and has many additives that plug up the heat exchangers in plumbing systems. Plumbing and RV antifreeze are generally Propylene Glycol based due to it being less toxic and generally "food safe". Since its used to winterize houses and RV's where people will possibly consume the water. It is good for preventing freezing but automotive antifreeze is better at preventing overheating.

Generally RV antifreeze is what we always use for the sprayer although windsheild washer fluid can be purchased a little cheaper.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [50 messages per page]
Jump to forum :
Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread

(Delete cookies)