AgTalk Home
AgTalk Home
Search Forums | Classifieds (105) | Skins | Language
You are logged in as a guest. ( logon | register )

Dump truck or end dump?
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [50 messages per page]
View previous thread :: View next thread
   Forums List -> Machinery TalkMessage format
 
bleedred
Posted 6/12/2013 22:31 (#3152808)
Subject: Dump truck or end dump?



East Central Ia
We have two trucks with 5th wheels... And one tender setup. Nothing has a wet kit on it currently.

After seeing how much fill and rock we need to haul we will easily pay for a decent truck or trailer.

I am leaning towards a dump truck and finding a cheap pintle hitch trailer for hauling our 19k lbs excavator and skid steer.

Am I on the right track?
Top of the page Bottom of the page
d farm
Posted 6/12/2013 22:43 (#3152833 - in reply to #3152808)
Subject: Re: Dump truck or end dump?


nw iowa
My brother has 4 end dumps all but 1 got laid on its side. Go dump truck or side dump.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
shaun3480
Posted 6/12/2013 22:51 (#3152851 - in reply to #3152833)
Subject: Re: Dump truck or end dump?


Phillips Co NW Kansas
I agree. I haven't met an end dump I liked yet. Side dumpers are slick.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
dave morgan
Posted 6/12/2013 22:54 (#3152856 - in reply to #3152808)
Subject: RE: Dump truck or end dump?


Somerville, Indiana
I am leaning the same way, but gotta say we have two end dumps, one laid over in 1983 with a load of wet, wet corn...Have to be careful but it can be done...One the tag trailer side, trailer cost more for license that a semi trailer, but its shared with the dump truck...Dump truck is very handy, doesn't bother us hauling concrete if needed to get rid of an old floor and footings...DOT doesn't bother dump trucks and tag trailers here, never have seen one pulled over.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
bleedred
Posted 6/13/2013 00:24 (#3152980 - in reply to #3152856)
Subject: RE: Dump truck or end dump?



East Central Ia
I don't think a side dumper would be very handy for driveways.

Anything in particular to look for in a dump truck? Would haul everything from gravel, fill dirt, sand, concrete chunks, junk, steel...

I assume a steel box would be best? Are there different lift heights for the boxes? Our old grain truck never worked worth crap hauling dirt... Didn't ever want to come out.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Thumb Crop Farmer
Posted 6/13/2013 04:48 (#3153052 - in reply to #3152808)
Subject: Re: Dump truck or end dump?


Thumb of Michigan
End dump is fine, provided that the driver knows what he is doing. Keep the truck/trailer straight/dump on flat ground, dump into the wind etc.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Thud
Posted 6/13/2013 05:11 (#3153056 - in reply to #3153052)
Subject: Re: Dump truck or end dump?


Near-north Ontario, French River
DING DING DING... end dumps are just fine is the nut behind the wheel pays attention to what he is doing. I'm not saying they don't go over but its far from very common as some here at NAT would suggest. If you are just hauling gravel you will be just fine with an end dump, things like lime and heavy sticky/froze mud on uneven ground are what will take an end dump over.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
pat-michigan
Posted 6/13/2013 06:01 (#3153087 - in reply to #3153056)
Subject: Re: Dump truck or end dump?


UP / Thumb of Michigan
I've always been a little surprised by all the negative end dump comments as well. Not sure what we do right here, or what a lot of people seem to do wrong- but there's an incredible amount of "stuff" that gets moved with end dumps here every day. Grain, aggregates, coal, lime, fertilizer- the list goes on. Pretty rare to hear of one getting tipped over. I've been lucky I guess, but we've never flopped an end dump on our farm, and the first one came to the farm in 1972. I'm guessing that the majority of farms "here" have at least one end dump, have had at least one for a long time, and have never flopped one.

Not saying that it can't happen, I've seen it happen matter of fact. There were no mysteries ever in why a trailer tipped over, it was sometimes even predictable.

A dump truck is almost just as prone to tipping over as most trailers, you just have to work at it a little harder. All depends on a lot of factors if you want to compare things, but long story short it takes some common sense to keep either from tipping over. I wouldn't pick a dump truck solely on the theory that it won't tip over- it could happen. Myself, I always thought that one of the bigger advantages to a semi was the ability to hook a multitude of different trailers to the power unit. If I had two tractors and wanted to move some gravel or sand, I'd be looking for a trailer and a wet kit a lot harder than I'd be looking for another power unit to maintain.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
poor loser
Posted 6/13/2013 06:40 (#3153135 - in reply to #3153087)
Subject: Re: Dump truck or end dump?



north central ky
I agree, I would lean towards a cheap end dump and a cheap low boy. If you already have a couple semi's why add another engine to maintain, truck to insure and license every year.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
hf213
Posted 6/13/2013 07:12 (#3153174 - in reply to #3152808)
Subject: Re: Dump truck or end dump?


I have a dump trailer, then a tandem dump, and a single axle dump, I have hitches on all 3 trucks so that I can haul my backhoe on my tag trailer, but usually its hooked to my single axle truck, its easy to back in tight spots, and if doing small to medium jobs around houses or buildings, the single axle is handy there. For hauling large amounts then the dump trailer is handy, e.g. less trips to quarry, I look at it more in time savings than the fuel used, but I'm only 20 miles from either quarry I haul from. I do not mean to start a trailer fight here, but I like my frame trailer over a frameless especially when dumping in the field or a little rough terrain, I agree both can tip over, and a lot depends on cargo, time of year conditions, yada yada...just use good common sense, and take your time before dumping, but a poly liner sure helps and is worth every penny in any long bed dump, semi or straight truck, you will help the problem of sticking in the doghouse or sides, which can lead to the tipping. Just as a guide ,for me legally I can haul 16 ton on my tandem, 10 ton on the single and 23 ton on the dump. My tandem is usually the 1st truck out of the shed.....and future truck to replace this will be same length ( 20 ft ) but a triaxle.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
scott nelsen
Posted 6/13/2013 07:49 (#3153235 - in reply to #3153174)
Subject: Re: Dump truck or end dump?


Leeds, North Dakota
Lotta good posts, driver has to have common sense, dump trucks are handy, Scott.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
bleedred
Posted 6/13/2013 08:26 (#3153297 - in reply to #3153135)
Subject: Re: Dump truck or end dump?



East Central Ia
Lots a good advice guys.

What is a wet kit going cost me?

What should I look at in end dumps... Frame or frameless? Any other need to knows before I start calling and pricing?
Top of the page Bottom of the page
michigancornfarmer
Posted 6/13/2013 08:28 (#3153299 - in reply to #3152833)
Subject: Re: Dump truck or end dump?


well your brother must have some bad drivers. For one get off there butts after it loaded this is the main reason why dumps go over the loader loads them wrong that why they make a shovel holder on the front. Get out level the load, one loader loaded me on day the front of the dump right side floor was empty them the rear left side I shoveled but it didn't lay it over. We have 5 dumps from Gravel trains in Michigan to a 36' 3-9s dump they have come close but like in the opther post good drivers kept them up.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
scott nelsen
Posted 6/13/2013 08:37 (#3153315 - in reply to #3153297)
Subject: Re: Dump truck or end dump?


Leeds, North Dakota
http://www.forceamerica.com/ Jake depends what you want, gonna be close to 3 grand, gotta remember hyd hose doesn't come with it, got questions shoot me a email with contact #, Scott.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
pat-michigan
Posted 6/13/2013 08:38 (#3153320 - in reply to #3153297)
Subject: Re: Dump truck or end dump?


UP / Thumb of Michigan
I have no experience with frameless trailers. I've personally only witnessed one frameless trailer dump in my illustrious career. I'm going out on a limb and suggesting that we seldom hear of dumps flopping up here because we seldom have anyone using frameless trailers up here. There could be a couple of reasons why there aren't frameless dumps here, the number of axles we can run would be one of those reasons.

The one frameless I did watch trying to dump sugar beets appeared to be defying gravity just sitting there. I was pretty interested in seeing how it worked as I'd never seen one actually trying to dump anything, but I moved a substantial distance away when it got up past the first stage on the hoist. Scared me and I ain't afraid of nothin'.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
eyeballit
Posted 6/13/2013 08:42 (#3153324 - in reply to #3152808)
Subject: Re: Dump truck or end dump?


ne iowa
i have a steel frame end dump, with a steel box. it is HEAVY! too heavy. try to find a steel frame with alum. box. have come close to tipping mine over a few times.....scary. just always make sure you are level. i can't remember what a wet kit would cost now, probably around $1500, depending on if you can find a used pto or tank somewhere. a dump truck would be more nimble and more sturdy but i agree that it would just be another truck to maintain, which we all know isn't cheap.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
RodInNS
Posted 6/13/2013 11:05 (#3153517 - in reply to #3152808)
Subject: RE: Dump truck or end dump?


The pertinent questions would be... how far are you hauling material and what kind of situations are you dumping it into... If it's just short hauls of a mile or two then a tandem will work fine. If you're going 10 miles or more then you're probably getting into territory where a trailer is going to be much more productive... UNLESS you're working in hard to maneuver situations where a tandem can get in off the road more easily, etc.
Either way, you need to be careful. A tandem can be laid over too if the box is big enough and the load placed incorrectly. I've got a 16' box on mine with an air ride truck under it... and that requires caution on side slopes... or if someone gets the load too far forward... or it sticks or freezes.

Rod
Top of the page Bottom of the page
John Wollesen
Posted 6/13/2013 11:05 (#3153518 - in reply to #3152808)
Subject: Re: Dump truck or end dump?


Iowa
End Dumps are the way to go, you can haul Grain/Lime/Dirt/Sand etc. We would haul corn and then backhaul lime, You cant haul with a side dump into an ethanol plant. Like most said the ones that say be leary or know of guys who have tipped over, 99.9% of the time it's operator error.

Edited by John Wollesen 6/13/2013 11:08
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Thud
Posted 6/13/2013 13:04 (#3153651 - in reply to #3153087)
Subject: Re: Dump truck or end dump?


Near-north Ontario, French River
Pat I think the big difference is that in places like Ontario and Michigan there are often times 4-6 axles under a +41ft dump where as in the 80k states that same trailer ill have 2 axles right at the back so they run into stability issues, that or they are trying to dump frameless dumps. I've seen a couple of frameless dumps, I think if the driver farted on a breezey day the whole outfit would go over.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
BOGTROTTER
Posted 6/13/2013 15:06 (#3153763 - in reply to #3152808)
Subject: Re: Dump truck or end dump?


Kingston,Mi
Pat or Thumb Crop Farmer can challenge or change my calculations: 140,000 acres of beets with a ave. yield of 25 ton/acre and a guesstimate of 40 tons payload per anyone of several "Michigan Specials" is 87,500 truck loads of beets delivered from field to storage and then additional loads delivered or transferred between storage or plants over a 5 month campaign and not one flopped trailer that I am aware of. Haul beets until shut off then switch to hauling corn until the wet holding is full then go home.

I have never driven any truck/trailer setup but have had jobs where Gus Matonek delivered 5 to 6 doubles of rock material at 50 tons each and dumped them on a unprepared grass area for reloading to a rock truck for 5 days a week for a month and his operators didn't flop any singles or doubles.

From my perspective the only advantage a side dump has is it can not be raised into the power lines.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
poor loser
Posted 6/13/2013 20:25 (#3154172 - in reply to #3152808)
Subject: Re: Dump truck or end dump?



north central ky
If you start looking at end dumps I would recommend 30 ft or shorter. A couple of feet will make a huge difference dumping on uneven terrain. Actually, you never want to dump one unlevel (side to side). I used to do some custom hauling and people would call wanting a load of rock and they would tell me they had a good level spot. Well, 90% of the time it wasn't. So I kept a shovel on the trailer and would pop the rear gate and let some rock spill out and build me a ramp to back up onto. It was a little work but better than chancing a turn over. 30 footer can haul 1000 bushel of corn but not as sturdy while dumping. 28 footer holds 900 bushel and dumps lime better. I also have a 32 footer that holds 1100 but can be sketchy dumping lime. We also have added liners to all of our dumps and it makes a huge difference. Lime will start sliding out at lower heights. We have frame and frameless and they both are good. I prefer to pull my frameless but you won't find many short frameless trailers to choose from. We also have a truck that mainly stays close by and we made the passenger fuel tank an oil resivoir for the wet kit. I also would prefer a day cab truck when dumping lime in a field some where because I like to watch my trailer raise up through the back window.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [50 messages per page]
Jump to forum :
Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread

(Delete cookies)