|
|
South Central, IL | We are thinking about buying one of these tractors and I would like to know some of the pro's and con's of both machines and which one you guys would prefer. The tractor would be used to pull a 34ft. sunflower finisher in the spring and pull a reel disk and grain cart in the fall. We currently run mostly green stuff so we are partial to the John Deere auto-steer and we have 3 stores within a half hour of our farm, where as the closest challenger dealership is an hour away. |
|
| |
|
The Delta | Resale, bigger horsepower, and better dealers all point green. |
|
| |
|

| How does 65000 dollars cheaper for the Challenger sound?
That was the difference we were quoted. I have been running our new 765d all spring and love it. Quiet, powerful. The Sisu engine is supposed to be the Mercedes of ag engines.
I myself prefer def over egr any day, but that's my opinion. We run a 3rd party autosteer so brand for that does not matter.
If you can get a better price for the Deere, go for it. We could not. Besides we think Deere is overpriced.
Major difference is the Deere has the ivt as the only trans you can get.
For the few problems I have had Challenger has been right on top of getting me fixed. All I need to do is call my tech and he gets it fixed. Our dealer is making good strides in our area to keep their customers happy. If your Deere dealer treats you well then go for it. |
|
| |
|
Chanute, KS. | Better fuel economy better company to deal with and better price, point yellow
|
|
| |
|
Fort Morgan, CO | Friend of mine from college's family used to run Challenger track tractors and a Lexion combine but have recently bought two 8360RTs and S series combine. I think part of this may have to do with the fact that their Challenger dealer is practically gone now. I think you answered some of the most important parts of your question yourself. |
|
| |
|
| Ran a Challenger on planter this spring and it is really a nice tractor to run. Very quiet and used a little less than four tenths of a GPA on the planter 16 row. I also like the Def system a lot better. I don't think one tractor is way better than the other . Price and dealer would be more consideration for me. |
|
| |
|
 Wheatley, Arkansas | Cat isn't a better company to deal with here. They think farmers schedule everything like construction contractors, and charge accordingly. |
|
| |
|
NE SD | Using .4 gpa on a planter certainly isn't a bragging point. Our 9230 JD and even the old 9400 on 60' planters ran .2 or less. |
|
| |
|

| Same here, 8530 pulling a 32 row 15" 1790 at 6.8 MPH I was running 0.2.
For me it would be tough to give up IVT. If Cat, er , AGCO would put a CVT in the 700's I would be pushing for the 8539 to leave and a MT775D to show up. |
|
| |
|
| A good dealer realation is a must, Go with the BEST dealership. |
|
| |
|
| Farmer62 - 6/2/2013 20:12
Ran a Challenger on planter this spring and it is really a nice tractor to run. Very quiet and used a little less than four tenths of a GPA on the planter 16 row. I also like the Def system a lot better. I don't think one tractor is way better than the other . Price and dealer would be more consideration for me.
Idle back my friend, that is almost the exact fuel I used pulling a 32' FC good and deep in some rough plowed ground. With that size tractor, the bigger the planter you put behind it the less fuel per acre you're going to use. |
|
| |
|
| Didn't say it was great. Ran 1500 rpms Would have thought it should have done a little less on the planter. |
|
| |
|
 East Central Ia | Altorfer and Ziegler are probably the two best Ag Cat dealers in the country. It took us years to gain the confidence to switch from Case to Lexion... now i cant believe we waited so long.
Since then we have switched our Case Stieger to an 855C Challenger. If the money was there our MX305 would be gone today for a MT765D.
Granted we were impressed with the service our Deere dealer gave with a planter issue this spring as well. That has certainly earned them a chance to price us equipment, but i wont hold my breath for a good deal.
I too wish Agco would get their heads out of thier butts with the CVT! They have the best best transmission on the market and the best track tractor design... PUT THEM TOGETHER!
Edited by bleedred 6/3/2013 08:53
|
|
| |
|
MN | as stated, cats are great tractors, but jd resale will be higher. I haven't run an 8rt but our 8310R runs about .25-.3 gpa pulling a 66ft planter. pretty good I think. |
|
| |