AgTalk Home
AgTalk Home
Search Forums | Classifieds (67) | Skins | Language
You are logged in as a guest. ( logon | register )

6420 vs 6115D?
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [50 messages per page]
View previous thread :: View next thread
   Forums List -> Machinery TalkMessage format
 
greenpower
Posted 6/24/2012 20:01 (#2447575)
Subject: 6420 vs 6115D?


N/E Iowa
Been looking at a tractor to retire the ole 4020. Been looking for a good used 6420 MFD......But I see John Deere has a tractor thats similar too the 6420, looks to be 6115D. I don't know anything about these 6115D... If I'm leaning towards the 6420 MFD is there anything i shoud be aware of?? I found one (2004 with 2,700 hrs). It will be used to Mow hay, grind some feed, haul manure in the winter, and run a rock picker in the spring.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Fla Veggie Farmer
Posted 6/24/2012 20:16 (#2447624 - in reply to #2447575)
Subject: RE: 6420 vs 6115D?


Southeast Florida
I have several 6XXXD tractors, they are built in Mexico, very plain and simple. They have open center hydraulics and with a 9-speed power reverser. The 6420 will have PSC hydraulics and way more refined tractor. Personally I love the 6XXXD tractors because they were built on the KISS (Keep It Simple Stupid) theory.

Edited by Fla Veggie Farmer 6/24/2012 20:36
Top of the page Bottom of the page
twraska
Posted 6/24/2012 20:57 (#2447724 - in reply to #2447575)
Subject: RE: 6420 vs 6115D?


Wallis, TX
We had a 6420 IVT, got rid of it, lot of little things, mostly electrical, always seemed to be wrong. IMHO just too complicated to be reliable.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
funfarmr
Posted 6/24/2012 21:20 (#2447774 - in reply to #2447575)
Subject: Re: 6420 vs 6115D?


Ohio
We have a 6430 premium mfd. Been a great little tractor. Spends most of its time on the hammer mill grinding hog feed.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Millhouse
Posted 6/24/2012 21:34 (#2447805 - in reply to #2447575)
Subject: RE: 6420 vs 6115D?


South-central Nebraska
I was in the market awhile back to replace a JD4000 and 4555 with a larger utility tractor. I looked at the 6130D and although it was simple and had the KISS approach, I just didn't think it was that great of a deal for what you got. Made in Mexico, pretty plain cab, simple quad transmission, open cen hyd, 4 cyl engine, short wheelbase and cheap tires. It was exactly what I needed. But, when pricing upper end JD models and CaseIh Maxxums the price for what you got didn't compare. Ended up with a Maxxum 125 value that had a better cab, longer wheelbase, semi-powershift, 6 cyl engine, better tires and built heavier. I have had some troubles with the Maxxum, nothing major, but happy overall. Just another option to consider. All came down to price/what you got for me.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
havin'funfarming
Posted 6/24/2012 21:37 (#2447817 - in reply to #2447575)
Subject: RE: 6420 vs 6115D?


Manitoba, Canada
I have a 6420 with IVT, suspended axle, cab suspension and loader suspension. I am really happy with it. I did have a few issues with it at first. It would heat up pulling a load. Found out air gets trapped in the oil cooler and disrupts the coolant flow through it. It must have been a bit low when I bought it as I have never had to add any coolant since so it must have started out with some trapped air. The dealer had to pop a hose off quite a few times to get rid of the air. I also had a couple of injectors go bad just before warranty ended so they put on a new set. That was around 1200 hours. I now run fuel conditioner in every tankfull instead of once in a while. Since then it has run like a top and it now has around 4000 hours on it. Hope to get many more. It is used as a general chore tractor doing mainly loader work. Love the IVT for that. For general loader work and bale shredding it burns somewhere around 1.5 to 1.7 gal per hour, depending winter or summer fuel. I would not hesitate at all to buy another.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Fla Veggie Farmer
Posted 6/24/2012 21:58 (#2447887 - in reply to #2447805)
Subject: RE: 6420 vs 6115D?


Southeast Florida
What's the deal with that? I can buy them D series tractors under $30K loaded here. Our dealer brings in several hundred of them for sugarcane planting crews and sells them off at the end of the season with full warranty and about 500 hours.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
johnypop
Posted 6/24/2012 22:15 (#2447945 - in reply to #2447575)
Subject: RE: 6420 vs 6115D?


ND

Go with the 6420, proven tractor, nice to run and will have the closed center hydraulics. I would stay away from that taco tractor, CHEAP is what you will get.

Top of the page Bottom of the page
WWT1370
Posted 6/24/2012 22:17 (#2447956 - in reply to #2447887)
Subject: RE: 6420 vs 6115D?


just a wild guess, buy maybe not every dealer handles 100's of them. I could be wrong....
Top of the page Bottom of the page
johnwayne360
Posted 6/24/2012 22:54 (#2448062 - in reply to #2447887)
Subject: RE: 6420 vs 6115D?


near dyersville iowa
you should have told me that last fall..lol..bare bones tractor here they quote me list price for cash...
Top of the page Bottom of the page
todd67648
Posted 6/25/2012 00:45 (#2448339 - in reply to #2447945)
Subject: RE: 6420 vs 6115D?


You get what you pay for on these tractors. The 6420 is a nice and confortable tractor - a typical up-scaled Deere tractor. The 6D series is a very basic tractor to compete with the value-minded customers. It is a very decent tractor, but basically has cables and levers instead of sensors and switches. However, the wet clutch and Power-Reverser are nice additions. The open center hydraulics and stripped down cab is probably the negative side. Paint on the castings is not the typical Deere quality and it seem our friends south of the border have a hard time keeping the cab upholstry clean while assembly. Lastly, if you plan on installing a loader with grapple, be sure NOT to order the tractor with the loader ready kit installed at the factory. It is only available as a 2-function joystick, and to upgrade to the 3-function (for grapple), you have to throw everything away and start over. You cannot simply upgrade the 2-function valve up to a 3-function valve. My $.02
Top of the page Bottom of the page
hjmeyers
Posted 6/25/2012 07:28 (#2448454 - in reply to #2447575)
Subject: RE: 6420 vs 6115D?


north central iowa
Dad wanted a simple yard tractor and got a 6115D for $47,000 new with 4 year warrenty. Very simple and exactly what he wanted. Had good luck with it so far.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
pudding
Posted 6/25/2012 13:37 (#2448962 - in reply to #2447575)
Subject: Re: 6420 vs 6115D?


Somewhereville, Earth
isn't there a cheap mexican one available in red and blue in the US now i believe, based on NH grandparents, the TS6000 to TS6030 in blue, i don't know the numbers for red ones?

Top of the page Bottom of the page
johnwayne360
Posted 6/25/2012 14:16 (#2449016 - in reply to #2448962)
Subject: Re: 6420 vs 6115D?


near dyersville iowa
I know the farmall line is now made in turkey..I dont know about the other red ones off the top of my head.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Fla Veggie Farmer
Posted 6/25/2012 19:57 (#2449480 - in reply to #2448962)
Subject: Re: 6420 vs 6115D?


Southeast Florida

Yup, the TS-6000 series is Mexican built. They're making a hi-crop version of this one too.

Top of the page Bottom of the page
Campbell Farms
Posted 6/25/2012 21:54 (#2449778 - in reply to #2447575)
Subject: Re: 6420 vs 6115D?



Sw Mo
If you're completely torn between the two I'd lean towards the 6420. But if you're wanting something to replace your tried and true 4020 I'd be looking more at something like a 7210. I know it's a larger frame and possibly little higher priced, but it's a Waterloo tractor with a real motor 6 cyl. The small frame 7010s are a very solid built tried and true tractor, more comparable to the 4020s I would say.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
dt4020
Posted 6/25/2012 22:08 (#2449820 - in reply to #2449778)
Subject: Re: 6420 vs 6115D?


Fairbury, NE (Southeast)
agree, the wheelbase will be closer to the 4020, and a used one should be had for much less than 40k.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [50 messages per page]
Jump to forum :
Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread

(Delete cookies)