AgTalk Home
AgTalk Home
Search Forums | Classifieds (117) | Skins | Language
You are logged in as a guest. ( logon | register )

Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [50 messages per page]
View previous thread :: View next thread
   Forums List -> Machinery TalkMessage format
 
9670guy
Posted 1/2/2011 19:57 (#1522375)
Subject: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?


NW IL
Using 744 brents right now. They don't tow in tandem very well for me. Have 31mph tractor and not ready for headaches of a truck. Could buy trailer now and always add semi later. Does someone offer tandem dolly? What about brakes? TIA
Top of the page Bottom of the page
BHans
Posted 1/2/2011 20:08 (#1522417 - in reply to #1522375)
Subject: Re: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?


Angleton Texas
I have seen it done with the brakes backed off (dont know how legal it is ) flat ground should be ok
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Big Ben
Posted 1/2/2011 20:11 (#1522427 - in reply to #1522375)
Subject: RE: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?


Columbia Basin, Ephrata, WA
There are some pintle hitch dollys that you could hitch behind a tractor. I built a dolly with the back half of an old freightliner. The dolly has no brakes, and some trailers don't need air to roll. For brakes or to make newer trailers roll, you'd need some kind of air compressor, and then ?? I'd say at least a trailer hand valve in the cab if not some kind of automatic brake actuator.



(8130pullingbales.JPG)



Attachments
----------------
Attachments 8130pullingbales.JPG (80KB - 762 downloads)
Top of the page Bottom of the page
isustud
Posted 1/2/2011 20:20 (#1522459 - in reply to #1522427)
Subject: Is illegal in Illinois (Big time!!)


Dad got a $1,200.00 fine 15 years ago for pulling a semi trailer with a farm tractor, I would advise against it.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
9670guy
Posted 1/2/2011 20:22 (#1522468 - in reply to #1522459)
Subject: Re: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?


NW IL
Didn't know that thanks.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
cole05000
Posted 1/2/2011 20:28 (#1522491 - in reply to #1522375)
Subject: RE: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?


western iowa
Better get it set up for lights, brakes and get it figured out how much weight you can put on there. That set up would get me pulled over by every DOT that saw it. 2 Brent 544s pull really nice and you can haul 1100 bushels.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
JD fanatic
Posted 1/2/2011 20:31 (#1522497 - in reply to #1522427)
Subject: Re: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?


mw
You can cage the spring brakes to let them roll without air. Really simple, easier if you air up and release the brakes with a truck first then just put the caging tool in and run the nut tight on it.
Not sure on the legality of it, i suppose it differs state to state.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
MOjeeper
Posted 1/2/2011 20:34 (#1522505 - in reply to #1522375)
Subject: Re: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?



NEMO
Ed Boysen does.. But his tractor is equipped with air brakes.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
zeamax
Posted 1/2/2011 20:44 (#1522529 - in reply to #1522375)
Subject: Re: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?


I made a dolly from an old semi tractor and pull an old hopper without spring brakes. The place where you are really at risk is turning. If you try to slow down while turning, you can really feel the tractor being pushed. I have used it for several years and like it much better than pulling wagons.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
jeff gordon
Posted 1/2/2011 20:46 (#1522537 - in reply to #1522375)
Subject: RE: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?



Mather, Manitoba
why would you want to? You're not saving anything by doing it. Unless you have product to get off a massively wet field. You have to spend a few hours backing off brakes, hooking up lights and a converter dolly. You can rent a 20 yr old day cab for 500 a month.... and have your tractor freed up.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Smoothlander
Posted 1/2/2011 20:49 (#1522549 - in reply to #1522375)
Subject: RE: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?



Works great for moving hay but would not want to move grain without brakes.

Top of the page Bottom of the page
darkagro
Posted 1/2/2011 20:53 (#1522564 - in reply to #1522375)
Subject: RE: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?


Saskatchewan, Canada
I seen one guy who took the air pots off and put in small hyd clyinders. He just used the tractor hyd controls to apply and hold for park, nad he had some serious hills to go on.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Ron (Cen. IL.)
Posted 1/2/2011 20:54 (#1522567 - in reply to #1522468)
Subject: Re: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?


Central Illinois


I'm pretty sure you're limited to 18,000 pounds on each wagon axle too, so you could also get fined for the 700+ bushel wagons unless you only put around 500-550 bushel on them.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Topshot
Posted 1/2/2011 20:55 (#1522576 - in reply to #1522375)
Subject: Re: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?


Near Richmond, IN
Neighbor moves his Komatsu P200 excavator all around with his tractor and a lowboy trailer. Don't know how he's got it setup but pulls it with a FWA JD and the trailer has brakes, I do know that much. By all around, I mean he hauls it that way at least 10 miles to neighboring jobs. If they're much farther than that he hires a semi to move it.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Dan_wcIN
Posted 1/2/2011 20:56 (#1522577 - in reply to #1522505)
Subject: Re: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?



It made a Crop
Here's a link to Ed "B Train"

http://talk.newagtalk.com/forums/thread-view.asp?tid=33541&mid=2324...

And here's a link to the rebuild of it

http://www.boysungrain.com/trailer.htm
Top of the page Bottom of the page
dougpettman
Posted 1/2/2011 21:26 (#1522658 - in reply to #1522576)
Subject: Re: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?


Tillsonburg Ont
The small hydraulic cylinders were picked up at Princess Auto in Canada. They went off the tractor Hydraulics and worked well.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Dutchdeutz
Posted 1/2/2011 21:36 (#1522693 - in reply to #1522375)
Subject: Re: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?


Peace River, AB, Canada
Fendt or Deutz has airbrakes (factory installed) as an option on it,
Would make it easy to switch.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
farmerknowsbest
Posted 1/2/2011 21:46 (#1522724 - in reply to #1522375)
Subject: Re: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?


Morrisburg Ontario
It is legal up here in Ontario to do it with no brakes. We have been for a good 15 years with no problems. Loaded with corn is about 44000kg. No problem stopping with the tractors brakes. One night this fall we were hauling through a ride program, (checking for drunk drivers, very annoying, they stopped all of our trucks and tractors every time through for like 5 hours) and this combo was pulled over the they did a full road side inspection and found we were fully in compliance with the law.

We normally have it on our T7060 with 31mph tranny and it handles it fine at full speed.

Warren





Edited by farmerknowsbest 1/2/2011 21:57
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Ron (Cen. IL.)
Posted 1/2/2011 21:48 (#1522742 - in reply to #1522375)
Subject: RE: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?


Central Illinois

http://talk.newagtalk.com/forums/thread-view.asp?tid=117439&posts=1...

http://talk.newagtalk.com/forums/thread-view.asp?tid=135949&posts=2...
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Big Ben
Posted 1/2/2011 21:50 (#1522752 - in reply to #1522693)
Subject: Re: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?


Columbia Basin, Ephrata, WA
Most European tractors have air brakes. I think it's even an option on 31mph Deere 7000 series here.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Dennis SEND
Posted 1/2/2011 21:50 (#1522753 - in reply to #1522375)
Subject: Re: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?



John Deere 8030's and the new R series all have an air brake option they have a glad hand hookup on the back of the tractor just like a semi. Dennis SEND

http://salesmanual.deere.com/sales/salesmanual/en_NA/tractors/attac...

Edited by Dennis SEND 1/2/2011 21:57
Top of the page Bottom of the page
farmerknowsbest
Posted 1/2/2011 22:03 (#1522794 - in reply to #1522375)
Subject: Re: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?


Morrisburg Ontario
This T7070 autocommand has an air compressor to run the trailer brakes on this rig.



Warren

Edited by farmerknowsbest 1/2/2011 22:03
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Wabu
Posted 1/2/2011 22:23 (#1522862 - in reply to #1522375)
Subject: RE: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?



SW Ontario
We pull a grain trailer with a tractor. A truck dealer built us a tandem converter dolly with a fifth wheel on it. We put a pressure tank on the hitch of that dolley ( approx. 50 gal steel tank) and charge it up with our shop compressor to about 120 psi. We hook that up to the trailer with a parking brake and a hand valve in the cab. One charge of the pressure tank per day gives us enough air for breaking for a whole day. It's cheap, it works and it is a lot safer than no brakes at all!
Top of the page Bottom of the page
9670guy
Posted 1/2/2011 22:44 (#1522937 - in reply to #1522375)
Subject: Thanks guys NT


NW IL
.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
dap54
Posted 1/2/2011 22:50 (#1522951 - in reply to #1522375)
Subject: Re: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?


nw iowa
Why don't you like 2 744's in tandem? I know a neighbor that has 8 pairs of 740's, has pulled pairs for 20 some years.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
9670guy
Posted 1/2/2011 23:00 (#1522990 - in reply to #1522951)
Subject: Re: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?


NW IL
On highway it works OK, but on township roads (not very level) the rear wagon starts whipping around if u go over 22mph when loaded. Toe in is OK. Tongue is tight. Thought trailer would follow better, and be safer?
Top of the page Bottom of the page
deeredriver
Posted 1/2/2011 23:05 (#1523009 - in reply to #1522990)
Subject: Re: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?


Alma NE
Find a place that sells these over here in the states and have air over hydraulic brakes


http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/AIR-AND-OIL-BRAKE-ACTUATOR-FAST-TOW-TRAILER-/...

Top of the page Bottom of the page
beh
Posted 1/2/2011 23:07 (#1523019 - in reply to #1522375)
Subject: CSA 2010...


Heil Harvesting, Ulysses KS/Limon CO
May see more of this as CSA 2010 goes into effect here in 2011. They are going to make it rough on all truckers. Going to be a HUGE pain for those of us who truck as supplementary business to our primary business. That thing is scary. For some, it is just a matter of life, we have to have trucks--but I can see for a producer making relatively short deliveries this could be an option...

In KS you are still subject to axle weights but that is all. No licensing or anything. NE I believe is similar.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Kooiker
Posted 1/2/2011 23:59 (#1523137 - in reply to #1522567)
Subject: Re: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?



What is a single axle straight truck allowed to carry on the rear axle in Illinois?   18,000?  20,000?

Top of the page Bottom of the page
Kooiker
Posted 1/3/2011 00:02 (#1523142 - in reply to #1522375)
Subject: RE: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?



I'm not sure what "headaches of a truck" you would avoid by pulling a hopper bottom with a farm tractor.  I'd think a rig like that would be a like placing a bullseye on your trailer for the Dot to stop you.

 

Seems to me like you'd have all of the bad points of both rigs without the main benefit of a truck.

Top of the page Bottom of the page
John NW Ia
Posted 1/3/2011 00:57 (#1523197 - in reply to #1523142)
Subject: RE: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor? Iowa



Pocahontas, Ia

I realize the OP is in Illinois. Since you are in Iowa, I think these are the Iowa rules:

http://www.iowadot.gov/mvd/omve/truckguide.pdf  It is a PDF on page Sec. 1:61

A semi-trailer exclusively used in an agricultural operation may be considered an implement of husbandry if reconstructed by permanent attachment of a converter dolly. Reconstructed semi-trailers may be pulled by farm tractors and must meet the lighting requirements for implements, may claim exception from axle weight limits, and do not need to be registered. Semi-trailers connected to a detachable converter dolly are not reconstructed and not privileged to the implement exceptions.


There are other rules that apply but a friend claims this rule exempts him from axle weight and bridge laws.  The key is non-detachable converter dolly. 

He uses an air compressor attached to his PTO to power the air brakes with a hand valve inside the cab. 

Reconstructed Semi-trailers

Top of the page Bottom of the page
zipper
Posted 1/3/2011 07:27 (#1523325 - in reply to #1522724)
Subject: Re: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?


wondering if most tractors with duals would fit over the scales and in the dump area of most elevators?
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Andover
Posted 1/3/2011 08:03 (#1523376 - in reply to #1522375)
Subject: Re: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?


Guelph, Ontario
This is what we are using for the overflow the truck can't handle.
The 8225R had a hydraulic brake kit from the factory.



(IMG_0923_1.jpg)



Attachments
----------------
Attachments IMG_0923_1.jpg (54KB - 693 downloads)
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Kooiker
Posted 1/3/2011 08:23 (#1523404 - in reply to #1523197)
Subject: RE: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor? Iowa



Sounds like he better make DANG sure it is a non-detachable converter dolly before he loads it front to back and starts crossing old wooden bridges. 

Sounds like the kind of law where if you ask two different Dot officers you're gonna get two different answers.

 

Still, combining all of the headaches of a dumping a hopper with the slow travel speed of a tractor (yes he is talking about a fast tractor but its still slow) doesn't seem like that great of an idea to me.

Top of the page Bottom of the page
ezzard
Posted 1/3/2011 08:28 (#1523419 - in reply to #1522375)
Subject: Re: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?


SE IA
Used to pull a hopper bottom semi trailer with tractors. Make sure you have plenty of tractor on it or it will shove you around. When the tandems on the dolly are headed in one direction they have to be dragged to turn them, I spun a tractor out (in a circle) more than once trying to turn that thing. I put some small diameter hydraulic cylinders on the trailer to run the slack adjusters for brakes. IA DOT never bothered me and they had plenty of opportunities.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Andover
Posted 1/3/2011 08:48 (#1523468 - in reply to #1522658)
Subject: Re: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?


Guelph, Ontario
Does anyone have a # for those cylinders at Princess Auto? I can't seem to find any small "one way" cylinders on their site.


Edited by Andover 1/3/2011 08:49
Top of the page Bottom of the page
E718
Posted 1/3/2011 09:22 (#1523530 - in reply to #1523404)
Subject: RE: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor? Iowa


Sac & Story county IA



"Sounds like he better make DANG sure it is a non-detachable converter dolly before he loads it front to back and starts crossing old wooden bridges."

How about the little signs on the posted bridges that says "ALL VEHICLES"?

I read Iowa State University and Crawford County were doing some kind of research on bridges and the county engineer made the statement something like "it is legal on the road but not on the bridges" talking about manure tanks and grain cart axle loads. I have no idea what is the right answer. Or where to find out.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Kooiker
Posted 1/3/2011 09:52 (#1523574 - in reply to #1523530)
Subject: RE: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor? Iowa



What about the ones that aren't posted?

 

 

Common sense goes a long ways.  Thing is most people don't have much of it.

Top of the page Bottom of the page
dvswia
Posted 1/3/2011 11:34 (#1523739 - in reply to #1523197)
Subject: RE: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor? Iowa


sw corner ia.
so what makes the coverter dog permanent? it is a fifth wheel.. I have wondered about this very thing too.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
E718
Posted 1/3/2011 13:54 (#1523960 - in reply to #1523574)
Subject: RE: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor? Iowa


Sac & Story county IA
I don't know. I don't where to find the answer, either. I have never read anything about that. A person should know that stuff in advance of a "deal".
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Ron (Cen. IL.)
Posted 1/3/2011 14:21 (#1524003 - in reply to #1523137)
Subject: Re: Anyone pulling grain trailers with farm tractor?


Central Illinois


I'll say it's 18,000 but that may not be correct.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
John NW Ia
Posted 1/3/2011 14:51 (#1524040 - in reply to #1523960)
Subject: I was not referring to posted bridges



Pocahontas, Ia

He (and everybody) has to obey a posted bridge limit.  A non posted bridge has no limit.

I was talking about what is referred to as "bridge laws".  Gross weight is limited by axle group spacing.  See above link  Sec 1:20 or the chart in any truckers atlas.

Top of the page Bottom of the page
Flipper
Posted 1/3/2011 17:03 (#1524174 - in reply to #1522567)
Subject: NEED TO CHECK IL FARM EXEMPTION!!!!!



Hoffman, IL
I may be wrong but in IL the farm weight exemption is only to 36000 lbs. I don't know about you but have had a couple of people get some pretty hefty fines pulling these big wagons with a pickup. I haven't heard anyone getting a ticket with a tractor. I have heard of several people stopped for pulling trailers with tractors though. FWIW
-----
ALL DAYS ARE GOOD ITS JUST SOME ARE BETTER THAN OTHERS
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [50 messages per page]
Jump to forum :
Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread

(Delete cookies)