![]() | ||
| AgTalk Home | ||
| ||
How old of propane tank is too old?Jump to page : 1 Now viewing page 1 [50 messages per page] | View previous thread :: View next thread |
| Forums List -> Machinery Talk | Message format |
| shank |
| ||
| I thought I had propane leak soI called my dealer to come check it.He couldnt find any leaks ,but said he wasnt going to fill it anymore because its too old.He also said it was to close to the metal quonset. He has been filling it there for 40 years???????? | |||
| |||
| Gifford |
| ||
East Kansas, DeSoto | I think there are firms who pressure test them and re certify. At least I was told that. Gifford | ||
| |||
| Illinois Steve |
| ||
North Central Illinois | Not a good answer to your question but retailers are being pressured by insurance companies and regulatory issues to crack down on out of date equipment. While I am not aware of any set age limit like mentioned below you can have them checked out to see if they are sound. All of the retailers in this area have come out with programs to pressure and leak test every tank and line over the next few years. Here again it is to satisfy insurance and other regulations. I have a tank that is probably almost 40 years old and they checked it out and certified it recently. If it does not have a tag with a model and serial number they may balk at continuing to fill it. As far as being close to a building that is something else they are cracking down on. Just because it has been in the same spot for 40 years does not mean it is in a good spot. More regulations they are trying to comply with. It seems a little ridiculous I realize but don't blame the retailer they are just trying to make everyone happy. | ||
| |||
| jdflyer |
| ||
Centralia, MO | I've got a tank that has been around at least since 1966. This summer the relief valve let go and wouldn't seal back up completely so the propane company pumped it out, replaced all the valves, repainted and re-certified the whole system and pronounced it as good as new for about $300. | ||
| |||
| Thud |
| ||
Near-north Ontario, French River | Steve is right, the retailer is doing whats required for them to remain compliant and limit liability. Our fuel supplier ( diesel ) told us that if they fill a tank that doesnt meet code ( either the tank itself or the installation re: to close to buildings etc) and there is a spill/fire their insurance will not cover them for spill/fire/explosion damages , add to the fact that they would be charged for violating laws surrounding fuel storage etc. Went so far as to say there might even be a chance that the property owners insurance may refuse to pay as well, for the same reason, improper fuel storage . | ||
| |||
| justamerefarmer |
| ||
| propane cylinders should be retested every 10 years. there must be a stamp on the tank. I would think the bulk storage have the same regulations and are enforced now that the insurance is requiring the fuel suppliers to do so. | |||
| |||
| 4430 |
| ||
Little Egypt Southern Illinory | It's too old when your LP supplier refuses to fill it ! | ||
| |||
| Illinois Steve |
| ||
North Central Illinois | Not a good answer to your question but retailers are being pressured by insurance companies and regulatory issues to crack down on out of date equipment. While I am not aware of any set age limit like mentioned below you can have them checked out to see if they are sound. All of the retailers in this area have come out with programs to pressure and leak test every tank and line over the next few years. Here again it is to satisfy insurance and other regulations. I have a tank that is probably almost 40 years old and they checked it out and certified it recently. If it does not have a tag with a model and serial number they may balk at continuing to fill it. As far as being close to a building that is something else they are cracking down on. Just because it has been in the same spot for 40 years does not mean it is in a good spot. More regulations they are trying to comply with. It seems a little ridiculous I realize but don't blame the retailer they are just trying to make everyone happy. | ||
| |||
| Chuck |
| ||
Wolcottville,Indiana | Hi Loran, When I had a tank moved they asked how old it was, seems the older tanks had a lot more metal than the new ones do. Chuck | ||
| |||
| cr39 |
| ||
Northeast ks | I moved into one of our old farmhouses last fall and called the coop for propane. They wouldn't deliver propane because the guy said I didn't have a regulator where the propane line meets the house. I did have one on the tank. He didn't really give any more explanation, and I kept saying "it's been like this for 30 years or more". I just called another place and they came, did a leak test, and filled the tank, no questions asked. | ||
| |||
| Mike SE IL |
| ||
West Union, Illinois | justamerefarmer - propane cylinders should be retested every 10 years. there must be a stamp on the tank. I would think the bulk storage have the same regulations ... This gets into details and nit picking. DOT tanks can't be refilled until they are recertified if it is more than 12 years after manufacture date and every 5 years after that (I think that is current, that's what it was a few years ago when I was doing it). ASME tanks do not have to be recertified, but ARE required to have a legible data plate.So what is the difference? A DOT tank is a portable container like a BBQ grill tank or a 100 # cylinder. They can be as large as 420 # (about 100 gallons). An ASME tank is one not designed for transporting, a fixed tank like at the house or grain dryer. (I know, there are some ASME tanks used as portables for temporary locations. We won't get side tracked down that rabbit trail.) However I seem to recall some talk a few years ago about dates on the relief valves. I believe on bigger tanks (I forget the size affected, for sake of argument we'll say over 6,000 gallons but I'm sure that is not the exact number) Relief valves have a life and must be replaced within so many years of manufacture. They can go out of date on the shelf and can't be installed. As for locations, many many companies have been very lacking in common sense where tank locating is involved. What most people do not understand is they are not trying to protect you from the tank. They are trying to protect the tank from you! Tanks over 124 gallons have to be at least 10 feet, preferably 25 from a building .... ANY building. They can't be under a high voltage line, have stuff stacked around them, be in a traffic pattern, on and on. It all makes good sense, but often good sense is not involved. If your supplier is balking at filling a tank too close to a building GOOD FOR HIM! Sometimes you have to protect customers from themselves. I saw a 500 gallon tank one time set right up next to a garage with an overhanging ventilated soffit. If the relief valve actuated it would have put vapor right into the attic! One time I raised the lid on a tank to find the line to the house was cemented pvc plastic pipe! And it was installed by a licensed plumber! Here is an example from www.propane101.com The picture of the propane tank below illustrates the dangers of unsafe distances regarding relief valve proximity. The arrow labeled 1 is the propane safety relief valve. Arrow number 2 is a hot water heater. Arrow number 3 is the bed of an RV slide-out. If the relief valve were to fully open, the propane stream would be directly underneath the bed of this RV slide-out. If the relief valve opened and propane came in contact with the hot water heater flame (arrow #3), a dangerous situation would present itself immediately
The problem is propane is so safe people become careless. If tanks blew up every day and were constantly in the news people would be very aware of the risks and demand they be placed safely. But because LP has such a good track record people get careless and lazy. www.propane101.com is a very good site to visit It has lots of very good information
Edited by Mike SE IL 8/16/2010 22:27 | ||
| |||
| 5288 |
| ||
S.E. South Dakota | When i switched dealers he said all my tanks were fine.One was built in 1956,1968,1980,and 1995.The 1956 is hooked to my house.The rest are on bins. | ||
| |||
| Mike SE IL |
| ||
West Union, Illinois | cr39 - 8/16/2010 21:01 I moved into one of our old farmhouses last fall and called the coop for propane. They wouldn't deliver propane because the guy said I didn't have a regulator where the propane line meets the house. I did have one on the tank. He didn't really give any more explanation, and I kept saying "it's been like this for 30 years or more". I just called another place and they came, did a leak test, and filled the tank, no questions asked. Switch companies. They are not looking out for your best interest,they just want to sell gas.Current state of the art is to have a 2 stage system. ( see http://www.propane101.com/twostageregulatorsystem.htm ) The regulator at the tank drops the pressure to a few pounds, then the one on the house drops it to a fraction of a pound. This allows the use of smaller line between the tank and house, better control of the pressure, and a second safety if the regulator on the tank fails. And if the regulator on the tank is 30 years old they really are not looking out for your best interest. There is a piece of rubber in there that has been working through high temperatures and low, working constantly every day for 30 years. Even if you haven't been burning gas every day the regulator has been working. Every day this little flap of rubber has been working, moving, under pressure, in heat, in cold, in the contaminants in the fuel.
And if it fails you will go from having a pilot light to having a PILOT LIGHT. Think that could be dangerous? If your supplier came out, did a quick take a leak test, filled your tank, took your money and ran ... I suspect they are not looking out for your best interest. | ||
| |||
| Gerald J. |
| ||
| nt | |||
| |||
| Gerald J. |
| ||
| I just bought new regulators for this house. The one at the house was hidden under the back deck and I had to cut out a deck joist to let it spin off the iron pipe going through the basement wall. And frame around the new one because it wouldn't fit against that joist again. The old one at the tank had a 76 date code, matching the time this house was built but the second one had a 1970 date. Last fall it passed tests feeding a new furnaces, but I had the furnace guy out to reset the furnace after the regulators were changed. Total of the two bills about $200. But I won't have to worry about them for a decade or two. Gerald J. | |||
| |||
| plowboy |
| ||
![]() Brazilton KS | Tanks much larger then 100 gallons can be certified as DOT vessels. That is what they are doing with NH3 tanks which have illegible tags on them...they are somehow non-destructively inspected, hydrostatically pressure tested, and given a DOT certification number good for 5 years. I think it's the same process used on tankers. | ||
| |||
| Gerald_skca |
| ||
| Nice to see some common sense answers. The idea the regulations don't apply to my is cost us all money. Every time there is some stupid accident they come out with even more rules. Was just read about the nojave(sp?) race that killed 8 because they ignored general safety limits. Will this race ever continue after all the law suits get to court. | |||
| |||
| Jump to page : 1 Now viewing page 1 [50 messages per page] |
| Search this forum Printer friendly version E-mail a link to this thread |
| (Delete cookies) | |

How old of propane tank is too old?