AgTalk Home
AgTalk Home
Search Forums | Classifieds (58) | Skins | Language
You are logged in as a guest. ( logon | register )

Spikes, 3" or 4" twisted on chisel plow?
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [50 messages per page]
View previous thread :: View next thread
   Forums List -> Machinery TalkMessage format
 
bgunzy
Posted 9/20/2009 19:19 (#853900)
Subject: Spikes, 3" or 4" twisted on chisel plow?



Humeston, IA

I'm going through my father's JD 100 chisel plow to try some chiseling this fall.  It currently has spike points on it.  The spacing between shanks is 14-1/4" (out from 12" - I moved everything to compensate for 2 broken shanks).

Am considering putting 3" or 4" twisted points.  What has been your experience?  Which will turn more dirt and/or go deep? Thanks!

Top of the page Bottom of the page
Phred
Posted 9/20/2009 19:30 (#853909 - in reply to #853900)
Subject: RE: Spikes, 3" or 4" twisted on chisel plow?


NE Mo
My experience has been the twisted will not go in the ground like the spikes do, but they will move more dirt. HERE, I prefer the spikes.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
4thgen
Posted 9/20/2009 19:36 (#853919 - in reply to #853909)
Subject: Re: Spikes, 3" or 4" twisted on chisel plow?



missouri
we have twisted except on the back row where we run striaght points
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Dingaling
Posted 9/20/2009 20:12 (#853965 - in reply to #853900)
Subject: RE: Spikes, 3" or 4" twisted on chisel plow?



Owings, Maryland 38.6856 N 76.6752 W
I would make my decision based on your goal,,,, what are you trying to achieve ???? If you have plenty of horse up front and want maximum disturbance,,,, then it is 4" twisted. Little short on horse, maybe you don't need all the disturbance,,,, 3" twisted. Going to put spikes on,,,,, leave it in the shed !!!!!! Overall I use 3" twisted,,, keep 'em rollin and they do plenty of plowing.............
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Smoothlander
Posted 9/20/2009 20:16 (#853970 - in reply to #853900)
Subject: Re: Spikes, 3" or 4" twisted on chisel plow?



Will a JD 100 have enough trip force to pull a 4"?
Top of the page Bottom of the page
JonND
Posted 9/20/2009 20:16 (#853971 - in reply to #853900)
Subject: Re: Spikes, 3" or 4" twisted on chisel plow?


EC North Dakota
Not sure the 100 chisel plow will have enough tension in the springs to hold with 4" twists. They were designed for soil savers and most of them have a much higher trip pressure than any chisel plow. 3" should work, you may have to slow down depending on HP in front to allow shanks to stay where they belong.

Just my 2 penny worth of advice.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
4thgen
Posted 9/20/2009 20:52 (#854020 - in reply to #853971)
Subject: talking chisel plows



missouri
Does anyone pull a leveler or anything other attachments to smooth the ground for the next trip over?
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Smoothlander
Posted 9/20/2009 20:56 (#854025 - in reply to #853900)
Subject: Re: Spikes, 3" or 4" twisted on chisel plow?



Put a three bar harrow on it.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
John
Posted 9/20/2009 20:57 (#854026 - in reply to #853900)
Subject: RE: Spikes, 3" or 4" twisted on chisel plow?


Somewhere in North central Iowa
Personally, I think 4" would be too much. I'm not sure what you are doing with it but I have a similiar 3 pt. chisel I use for bean endrows and run spikes. I don't want or need to bury a lot of trash. If I did I would run a 3" twist. The spikes go deeper and pull easier not that hp is an issue for me.

John
Top of the page Bottom of the page
shepard
Posted 9/20/2009 21:08 (#854047 - in reply to #853900)
Subject: Re: Spikes, 3" or 4" twisted on chisel plow?



North Central Ohio
was told spikes bury about 25 % 3in bury 60% 4in bury90% never pulled spikes but u can tell the 4in are on there.have a 9 shank levler on the backwith f c shovels it levels pretty good,one pass in the spring.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
bgunzy
Posted 9/20/2009 21:09 (#854049 - in reply to #853900)
Subject: Re: Spikes, 3" or 4" twisted on chisel plow?



Humeston, IA
FYI - the chisel has no trips, just standard shanks. That would probably preclude the 4" twisted points, I'm guessing...
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Smoothlander
Posted 9/20/2009 21:17 (#854068 - in reply to #853900)
Subject: Re: Spikes, 3" or 4" twisted on chisel plow?



There is two springs on each shank, correct?
Top of the page Bottom of the page
bgunzy
Posted 9/20/2009 21:29 (#854099 - in reply to #854068)
Subject: Re: Spikes, 3" or 4" twisted on chisel plow?



Humeston, IA
No springs. Are rigid, like in the picture: http://salesmanual.deere.com/sales/salesmanual/en_NA/primary_tillag...
Top of the page Bottom of the page
5288
Posted 9/20/2009 21:41 (#854118 - in reply to #854099)
Subject: Re: Spikes, 3" or 4" twisted on chisel plow?


S.E. South Dakota
With soild mounted shanks i would stay with straight points.I think you may bust shanks with twists.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
mudracer
Posted 9/21/2009 07:48 (#854494 - in reply to #854118)
Subject: I have new 4" for sale, with hard surface.


south east north Dakota
.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [50 messages per page]
Jump to forum :
Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread

(Delete cookies)