AgTalk Home
AgTalk Home
Search Forums | Classifieds (58) | Skins | Language
You are logged in as a guest. ( logon | register )

Snow Pusher vs Snow Bucket
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [50 messages per page]
View previous thread :: View next thread
   Forums List -> Machinery TalkMessage format
 
Silver97
Posted 11/16/2023 10:06 (#10484224)
Subject: Snow Pusher vs Snow Bucket


South Dakota
Recently purchased a Bobcat T650 which has moved my JD 3010 to back up. I have room to push snow out of the way and only have minor close quarters removal to do. Do I want a snow pusher or do I want a snow bucket? Which size for each.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
jd4930
Posted 11/16/2023 10:15 (#10484230 - in reply to #10484224)
Subject: RE: Snow Pusher vs Snow Bucket


Central ND
Long runs and broad areas pusher hands down, short runs and tight areas with backdragging and such you'll want the bucket
Top of the page Bottom of the page
JAnderson
Posted 11/16/2023 10:26 (#10484243 - in reply to #10484224)
Subject: RE: Snow Pusher vs Snow Bucket


McCanna, ND
The right answer is both. I have a 8’ wide pusher with extra deep sideboards, it’s to much in wet snow in powder a 10-12’ with rubber cutting edge would be ideal.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
ctnfarms
Posted 11/16/2023 10:55 (#10484276 - in reply to #10484224)
Subject: RE: Snow Pusher vs Snow Bucket


NW IA
I have a pusher I'm looking to sell. Let me know if your interested. Bought a loader tractor so don't use my skid loader much anymore.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
KFLAgri
Posted 11/16/2023 11:19 (#10484305 - in reply to #10484224)
Subject: RE: Snow Pusher vs Snow Bucket


SW Ontario
I have a wheeled L185 New Holland. I had a 7’ flat back snow pusher and hated it, couldn’t push anything. Went to an 8’ bucket and can push snow like you wouldn’t believe. Bucket puts some weight on the skidsteer that you don’t get with a pusher. Bucket is 8’ wide, 4’ deep and 4’ tall. Now a pusher with a rounded back that will roll the snow might work as good or maybe better but the straight back pusher was a nightmare. Ended up just using the dirt bucket till I got the big snow bucket
Top of the page Bottom of the page
zach_deerefan
Posted 11/16/2023 11:35 (#10484318 - in reply to #10484224)
Subject: RE: Snow Pusher vs Snow Bucket


WCIA
I have both. They each work better in certain conditions, but if I had to choose one it would be the bucket. With snow in the bucket you have weight for traction, so seems I can push more and get stuck less.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
FFJR
Posted 11/16/2023 11:51 (#10484339 - in reply to #10484224)
Subject: RE: Snow Pusher vs Snow Bucket



nc IA
8' pusher on a 6300 mfwd is great. I could see the large snow bucket being an advantage on the skidloader possibly. I like the pusher on the loader as I can cycle and stack much faster then bucket work. Very deep drifts it's almost too big, but you can move so much volume with each pass vs the 7' bucket. and for not digging in it's great as well. The snow bucket on a skidloader - the weight transfer could be a aid and you have a better idea of your cutting edge vs loader. The 3010, the pusher won't take weight off your rear drives like the bucket would, and I'm sure the hyd arn't quick for dumping with a bucket, so the pusher saves time each pass there too.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
in-too-deep
Posted 11/16/2023 12:09 (#10484357 - in reply to #10484224)
Subject: RE: Snow Pusher vs Snow Bucket


56676
Pusher, if you have grippy z-pattern tracks. I think a floating pusher box like Virnig would be good for a farm. Atleast a rubber cutting edge. You can back drag pretty well with a pusher, but you can't get as close as you can with a bucket. Do your fine work with a dirt bucket, and push it the hell outta the way with the box. Could probably handle a 10' box if you have cold, dry snow. But you need traction.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Lone Wolf Picker
Posted 11/16/2023 12:18 (#10484369 - in reply to #10484318)
Subject: RE: Snow Pusher vs Snow Bucket


Black Hawk County, IA
Protech and HLA both make pushers with roll forward pull back edges. You have the best of both worlds then. We have a Virnig like that has rubber edges, works ok, but use it way more to clean the concrete in pole buildings. We plow with steel edges as I have areas to pile snow on the gravel so it can be scattered back on the drives. I won’t allow snow/ice pack around here.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
farmdude
Posted 11/16/2023 12:24 (#10484378 - in reply to #10484357)
Subject: RE: Snow Pusher vs Snow Bucket


Bucket.If thats all you get.It will work most off the time.Just a pusher you will be screwed alot off the time.Get an old F10 Farmhand bucket.You can make brackets that will fit most skidloaders.Move a ton off snow with that.Im not to imprrssed by the size off some off these buckets for especially for snow.Good Luck.

Edited by farmdude 11/16/2023 12:27
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Tomcat
Posted 11/16/2023 12:51 (#10484412 - in reply to #10484224)
Subject: RE: Snow Pusher vs Snow Bucket



Ludington/Manistee MI area
Boss V plow
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Cliff SEIA
Posted 11/16/2023 13:20 (#10484441 - in reply to #10484412)
Subject: RE: Snow Pusher vs Snow Bucket


2nd that.



(20230120_121902 (full).jpg)



Attachments
----------------
Attachments 20230120_121902 (full).jpg (206KB - 53 downloads)
Top of the page Bottom of the page
mmaddox
Posted 11/16/2023 14:44 (#10484517 - in reply to #10484441)
Subject: RE: Snow Pusher vs Snow Bucket


Hard to find one tool that meets all needs, except maybe a hammer/crescent wrench/vise-grips.
Both snow moving, and others have their place. How many tractor pictures out there with a loader and bucket or blade on the front, and a blade or blower on the back?
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Iowa4thgen
Posted 11/16/2023 15:40 (#10484571 - in reply to #10484224)
Subject: RE: Snow Pusher vs Snow Bucket


Iowa
I like a bucket for around a farm so you can actually pick up and move the snow to other areas if needed. A large parking lot a pusher might be quicker. I built a 9ft wide 3ft high and 3ft deep snow bucket that can move quite a bit of snow.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
ndred
Posted 11/16/2023 15:55 (#10484580 - in reply to #10484571)
Subject: RE: Snow Pusher vs Snow Bucket


s nd
I use a 10 ft pusher on a deere 74 hp skid steer. 324G. But I push snow a long ways to get it out of the yard for spring thaw. I clean around the doors and buildings with the bucket pulling back. I went bigger so I could get rid of 2 inches of snow. I don't like wet feet. But I see pushers are expensive now. I'm not sure I would want to dump the bucket every time. Not as much sticking, too. But that's all you get to do with it is push snow.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
MaineFarmer
Posted 11/16/2023 17:03 (#10484638 - in reply to #10484580)
Subject: RE: Snow Pusher vs Snow Bucket


coast of Maine
Friend,"you need a snow pusher,,you need a snow pusher,,,you need a snow pusher'....well he was plowing a commercial account with a JD 125 hp 4wd.Worked really well until he hooked a granite curb while cooning it .Twisted the loader and it doesn't set straight ever .The big round tube in JD loader some how twisted,,,I will stick with a bucket.I think they need to cut it and re -weld a pipe piece inside,,,
Top of the page Bottom of the page
jeff gordon
Posted 11/16/2023 18:16 (#10484706 - in reply to #10484224)
Subject: RE: Snow Pusher vs Snow Bucket



Mather, Manitoba
Long lane? Pusher or blade that can be angled
Top of the page Bottom of the page
jd8850
Posted 11/16/2023 20:58 (#10484942 - in reply to #10484224)
Subject: RE: Snow Pusher vs Snow Bucket


Roseglen, North Dakota
Both. You must already have a bucket. Never saw a skidsteer without one.
If not you can buy one cheap.
Pushers not so much.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
FuRuss
Posted 11/16/2023 20:59 (#10484943 - in reply to #10484224)
Subject: RE: Snow Pusher vs Snow Bucket


Tractor with a bucket on one end and a box scraper and an angle blade on the 3 point . When im doing short driveways the box scraper longer lanes the angle blade
Top of the page Bottom of the page
tims9220
Posted 11/16/2023 21:11 (#10484971 - in reply to #10484224)
Subject: RE: Snow Pusher vs Snow Bucket


east central wi
get a Kage plow or Bobcat has the exact same plow
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Silver97
Posted 11/16/2023 21:40 (#10485011 - in reply to #10484942)
Subject: RE: Snow Pusher vs Snow Bucket


South Dakota
Yes I have a 78" Dirt bucket but seems like it would take alot of time. It could be used for the close quarters work. I realize that you could spend 15K on skidloader snow attachments and still not have them all. I'm hoping that I can buy something and not use it. The problem is if I don't buy something it'll look like the winter of 22-23 around here.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Jump to page : 1
Now viewing page 1 [50 messages per page]
Jump to forum :
Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread

(Delete cookies)