AgTalk Home
AgTalk Home
Search Forums | Classifieds (63) | Skins | Language
You are logged in as a guest. ( logon | register )

NE Soil Builder
View previous thread :: View next thread
   Forums List -> Crop TalkMessage format
 
dko_scOH
Posted 4/17/2024 09:31 (#10709905 - in reply to #10709763)
Subject: RE: NE Soil Builder



39.48, -82.98
Ed Winkle was more like Soil Life than many on here will admit. I remember presenting him with hard data from an on-farm T-22 trial. T-22 was the PivotBio of that time. Well, I found no statistically significant response. From his weak reply, it was obvious he had never conducted a valid test with controls and done the stats. He relied on anecdotal evidence and apparently ignored anything that didn't fit his expectations. I don't know that he ever stopped recommending and selling T-22.

That said, he did have some legitimate agronomy in his conversations. You might pick up tidbits of information or catch a different insight from time to time. Plus, he was forthcoming with suggestions in this public forum, was more humble than Soil Life, and certainly more civil than NE Soil Builder. People truly miss Ed.
Top of the page Bottom of the page

  • RE: NE Soil Builder - illinidirtfarmer : 4/17/2024 19:41
  • RE: NE Soil Builder - sand85 : 4/17/2024 21:00
  • RE: NE Soil Builder - NE Soil Builder : 4/17/2024 20:31
  • RE: NE Soil Builder - Pvafarm : 4/17/2024 06:59
  • RE: NE Soil Builder - Baby Robin : 4/17/2024 08:02
  • RE: NE Soil Builder - kb ag : 4/17/2024 09:05
  • RE: NE Soil Builder - Niese : 4/17/2024 09:24
  • RE: NE Soil Builder - dko_scOH : 4/17/2024 09:31
  • RE: NE Soil Builder - high crop : 4/17/2024 21:11
  • RE: NE Soil Builder - MNfarmer85 : 4/18/2024 00:37
  • RE: NE Soil Builder - Dan Michigan : 4/17/2024 13:11
  • Jump to forum :
    Search this forum
    Printer friendly version
    E-mail a link to this thread

    (Delete cookies)