Printer friendly copy of thread

What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people?

Posted 2/18/2026 08:48 (#11555932 - in reply to #11555888)
Subject: RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people?

Upper Midwest

Pofarmer - 2/18/2026 08:08

This may come as a shock, but the Biden administration tried mightily to get undocumented immigrants ITIN's. Why? Because then they're interacting with the system.

And the next step, "Able to vote"?

What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - JonSCKs : 2/17/2026 07:21
- RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Cisco : 2/17/2026 07:26
  - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - humblefarmer : 2/17/2026 09:45
  - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - hillclimber : 2/17/2026 17:12
  - That’s impossible.. for some there is no way back. - JonSCKs : 2/18/2026 22:21
    - Why? Trump’s architect of these policies Stephen Millers own Uncle says he’s a Racist. - JonSCKs : 2/18/2026 22:54
      - The Trump administration has changed rules and procedures to obtain citizenship. - JonSCKs : 2/18/2026 23:02
- RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Since1889 : 2/17/2026 07:27
  - This Propaganda is not supported by the FACTs - JonSCKs : 2/18/2026 23:17
    - DHS leadership is incompetent. - JonSCKs : 2/18/2026 23:43
    - RE: This Propaganda is not supported by the FACTs - David : 2/19/2026 06:45
      - The Cato paper is an UPDATE from the National Academy of Sciences. - JonSCKs : 2/19/2026 07:16
        
        RE: The Cato paper is an UPDATE from the National Academy of Sciences. - David : 2/19/2026 07:34
        
        So the smart people at the National Academy of Sciences got it wrong? - JonSCKs : 2/19/2026 07:41
      - This testimony is correct.. immigrants do jobs enabling other jobs in the US. - JonSCKs : 2/19/2026 08:08
- RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - featherfarmer : 2/17/2026 07:29
  - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - silverluv75 : 2/17/2026 07:35
    - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - ehoff : 2/17/2026 07:47
      - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/17/2026 08:43
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - sodsaver : 2/17/2026 08:47
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - sodsaver : 2/17/2026 08:49
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - SchitzCreekFarm : 2/17/2026 09:40
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Baby Robin : 2/17/2026 10:16
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/17/2026 10:51
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Baby Robin : 2/17/2026 12:26
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - hillclimber : 2/17/2026 16:26
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Baby Robin : 2/17/2026 16:59
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - ehoff : 2/17/2026 10:33
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/17/2026 11:00
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - tmrand : 2/17/2026 12:29
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - sodsaver : 2/17/2026 14:04
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - tmrand : 2/17/2026 23:47
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - sawinc : 2/17/2026 15:08
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - hillclimber : 2/17/2026 16:17
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/17/2026 16:55
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - neukm : 2/17/2026 22:01
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/17/2026 22:18
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Baby Robin : 2/18/2026 07:36
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/18/2026 08:04
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - havin’funfarming : 2/20/2026 13:30
    - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Hick : 2/17/2026 08:20
      - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - JRosenberger : 2/17/2026 08:41
- RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - ehoff : 2/17/2026 07:52
- RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - centralmnangus : 2/17/2026 08:02
- RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - FarmingMo : 2/17/2026 08:03
- RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - cornstalk : 2/17/2026 08:07
  - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - sodsaver : 2/17/2026 08:27
    - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - cornstalk : 2/17/2026 08:35
    - Yes.. pretty much. - JonSCKs : 2/19/2026 07:46
- RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Hick : 2/17/2026 08:08
- RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - CMN : 2/17/2026 08:15
  - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - tech-guy : 2/17/2026 08:27
    - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - CMN : 2/17/2026 08:46
- RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Fetv : 2/17/2026 08:21
  - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - tmrand : 2/17/2026 12:32
    - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Fetv : 2/17/2026 13:01
      - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/17/2026 13:12
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Fetv : 2/17/2026 15:45
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - illinidirtfarmer : 2/17/2026 17:56
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Fetv : 2/17/2026 21:10
- RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Gearclash : 2/17/2026 08:31
  - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - sawinc : 2/17/2026 14:50
- RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - sodsaver : 2/17/2026 08:41
  - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - jdironman : 2/17/2026 12:25
    - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - CMN : 2/17/2026 12:54
      - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Cisco : 2/17/2026 13:07
      - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million peopl - jdironman : 2/17/2026 15:13
      - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - hillclimber : 2/17/2026 16:35
    - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/17/2026 12:57
      - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - jdironman : 2/17/2026 14:22
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/17/2026 14:27
      - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - JRosenberger : 2/17/2026 15:33
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/17/2026 15:39
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - JRosenberger : 2/17/2026 16:00
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - David : 2/17/2026 16:32
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - hillclimber : 2/17/2026 16:38
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/17/2026 16:58
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - illinidirtfarmer : 2/17/2026 18:01
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/17/2026 18:07
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Nidaho : 2/19/2026 00:30
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/19/2026 08:34
        US men who do not work.. 10 million who have left since 2,000. - JonSCKs : 2/19/2026 09:29
        
        RE: US men who do not work.. 10 million who have left since 2,000. - Nidaho : 2/19/2026 10:55
        RE: US men who do not work.. 10 million who have left since 2,000. - Pofarmer : 2/19/2026 11:01
        
        RE: US men who do not work.. 10 million who have left since 2,000. - JonSCKs : 2/19/2026 13:38
  - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - David : 2/17/2026 16:20
    - Different Reality answers this best.. Obama Biden deported at the border - JonSCKs : 2/19/2026 09:43
      - RE: Different Reality answers this best.. Obama Biden deported at the border - David : 2/19/2026 09:55
        
        I’m against Illegal activity.. but we do need workers. - JonSCKs : 2/19/2026 10:08
        
        RE: I’m against Illegal activity.. but we do need workers. - David : 2/19/2026 10:10
        
        Murder. Which is Illegal. - JonSCKs : 2/19/2026 10:16
        
        RE: Murder. Which is Illegal. - David : 2/19/2026 10:19
        
        Really? - JonSCKs : 2/19/2026 13:54
        
        RE: Murder. Which is Illegal. - tmrand : 2/19/2026 10:21
        
        RE: Murder. Which is Illegal. - Pofarmer : 2/19/2026 11:05
        
        RE: Murder. Which is Illegal. - tmrand : 2/19/2026 11:10
        
        RE: Murder. Which is Illegal. - Pofarmer : 2/19/2026 11:14
        
        RE: Murder. Which is Illegal. - tmrand : 2/19/2026 12:13
        
        RE: Murder. Which is Illegal. - Pofarmer : 2/19/2026 12:20
        
        RE: Murder. Which is Illegal. - David : 2/19/2026 12:15
        
        RE: Murder. Which is Illegal. - Pofarmer : 2/19/2026 12:18
        
        RE: Murder. Which is Illegal. - David : 2/19/2026 12:40
        
        RE: Murder. Which is Illegal. - Pofarmer : 2/19/2026 15:23
        
        RE: Murder. Which is Illegal. - David : 2/19/2026 18:36
        
        RE: Murder. Which is Illegal. - Pofarmer : 2/19/2026 21:56
        
        RE: Murder. Which is Illegal. - David : 2/20/2026 06:56
      - RE: Different Reality answers this best.. Obama Biden deported at the border - Pofarmer : 2/19/2026 10:53
- RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Tech-freak : 2/17/2026 08:41
  - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - sodsaver : 2/17/2026 08:44
    - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - featherfarmer : 2/17/2026 08:51
      - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/17/2026 08:55
    - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - johnypop : 2/17/2026 08:59
    - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - David : 2/17/2026 16:34
- RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - DCH : 2/17/2026 08:57
  - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - hlstark : 2/17/2026 09:26
    - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/17/2026 09:42
      - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - hlstark : 2/17/2026 09:50
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - RecreationalTillage : 2/17/2026 10:31
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/17/2026 10:52
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - SWMustang : 2/18/2026 15:10
        
        GDP = Workers x Productivity. - JonSCKs : 2/17/2026 11:32
        
        RE: GDP = Workers x Productivity. - Fetv : 2/17/2026 17:08
        RE: GDP = Workers x Productivity. - jd7520 : 2/18/2026 07:22
        
        Addressed this above.. but repeating.. - JonSCKs : 2/19/2026 10:02
    - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - jdironman : 2/17/2026 14:31
      - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/17/2026 15:43
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - jdironman : 2/17/2026 17:40
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/17/2026 17:45
      - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - hlstark : 2/17/2026 17:21
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - jdironman : 2/17/2026 17:49
- RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - ks_cover_crop : 2/17/2026 08:58
- RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Little papa : 2/17/2026 10:19
  - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/17/2026 10:54
    - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Little papa : 2/17/2026 11:46
      - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/17/2026 12:13
    - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Busted Piston : 2/17/2026 13:28
      - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/17/2026 14:18
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - jdironman : 2/17/2026 14:39
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/17/2026 15:29
- RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - timebandit : 2/17/2026 10:38
- In the end it will be a positive impact - R2D2 : 2/17/2026 11:12
- RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - tmrand : 2/17/2026 12:40
  - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/17/2026 12:53
    - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - tmrand : 2/17/2026 13:26
  - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - CMN : 2/17/2026 13:06
- RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - centralmnangus : 2/17/2026 13:46
  - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - jdironman : 2/17/2026 14:46
    - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/17/2026 15:26
      - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - 806 Southern In : 2/17/2026 16:07
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - hlstark : 2/17/2026 17:33
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - David : 2/17/2026 17:53
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - 806 Southern In : 2/18/2026 01:14
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/18/2026 08:08
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - featherfarmer : 2/18/2026 08:48
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/18/2026 10:51
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - featherfarmer : 2/18/2026 11:29
        
        RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Pofarmer : 2/18/2026 12:02
      - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - hillclimber : 2/17/2026 16:46
- RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - FromtheFlats : 2/17/2026 14:21
- RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - hillclimber : 2/17/2026 16:10
  - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - hlstark : 2/17/2026 17:34
    - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - jdironman : 2/17/2026 17:54
- RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - Reality speaks : 2/17/2026 17:12
  - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - David : 2/17/2026 17:13
- Seriously? - bb1 : 2/17/2026 17:29
- RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - PeteMN : 2/17/2026 19:38
  - RE: What will the economic fallout be from deporting.. say 4 million people? - swtcorn wi : 2/18/2026 01:44
- RE: Who Jon and Po defend - David : 2/18/2026 05:38
  - RE: Who Jon and Po defend - jd7520 : 2/18/2026 07:17
  - RE: Who Jon and Po defend - Pofarmer : 2/18/2026 08:13
    - RE: Who Jon and Po defend - David : 2/18/2026 08:15
      - RE: Who Jon and Po defend - Pofarmer : 2/18/2026 09:07
        
        RE: Who Jon and Po defend - David : 2/18/2026 09:09
        
        RE: Who Jon and Po defend - Pofarmer : 2/18/2026 10:52
        
        RE: Who Jon and Po defend - David : 2/18/2026 11:11
        
        RE: Who Jon and Po defend - Pofarmer : 2/18/2026 12:04
        
        RE: Who Jon and Po defend - David : 2/18/2026 12:06
        
        RE: Who Jon and Po defend - swtcorn wi : 2/18/2026 16:29
        
        RE: Who Jon and Po defend - David : 2/18/2026 16:33
        
        RE: Who Jon and Po defend - swtcorn wi : 2/18/2026 17:47
        
        RE: Who Jon and Po defend - David : 2/18/2026 17:51
        
        Then we agree.. - JonSCKs : 2/19/2026 14:14
        
        RE: Who Jon and Po defend - tmrand : 2/18/2026 20:53
        
        RE: Who Jon and Po defend - Pofarmer : 2/18/2026 21:50
        
        RE: Who Jon and Po defend - David : 2/19/2026 06:40
        
        RE: Who Jon and Po defend - Pofarmer : 2/19/2026 08:44
        
        RE: Who Jon and Po defend - David : 2/19/2026 09:50
        
        RE: Who Jon and Po defend - Pofarmer : 2/19/2026 10:57
        
        RE: Who Jon and Po defend - David : 2/20/2026 07:00
        
        RE: Who Jon and Po defend - tmrand : 2/19/2026 07:41
        
        RE: Who Jon and Po defend - Pofarmer : 2/19/2026 08:42
        
        RE: Who Jon and Po defend - tmrand : 2/19/2026 09:32
        
        RE: Who Jon and Po defend - David : 2/19/2026 09:53
        RE: Who Jon and Po defend - Pofarmer : 2/19/2026 10:56
        
        Human Rights groups are documenting abuses. - JonSCKs : 2/19/2026 14:22
        
        RE: Human Rights groups are documenting abuses. - Pofarmer : 2/19/2026 21:57
      - RE: Who Jon and Po defend - Pofarmer : 2/18/2026 09:09